Examining Inspiration Across Cultures on Social Media
A study comparing inspiring social media posts from India and the UK.
― 5 min read
Table of Contents
- The InspAIred Dataset
- Data Collection Process
- Machine-Generated Content
- Analyzing Inspiring Content
- Linguistic Style and Structure
- Understanding Topics in Posts
- The Emotional and Cognitive Aspect of Inspiration
- Findings in Indian vs. UK Posts
- Comparing Real and AI-Generated Posts
- Can Machines Detect Inspiration?
- Training the Model
- Results of Machine Detection
- Implications of the Study
- Applications in Daily Life
- Contribution to Academic Research
- Conclusion
- Original Source
- Reference Links
Inspiration has a big role in our lives. It can lead to more creativity, better productivity, and even happiness. However, not much effort has been made to figure out what kinds of content inspire people. Most studies have focused mainly on Western societies, leaving a gap in understanding how inspiration works in different cultures.
This study aims to look at inspiration in social media Posts from various cultures, particularly comparing those from India and the UK. We use modern technology to examine and gather examples of inspiring posts, including those created by machines.
The InspAIred Dataset
To conduct this study, we gathered a new dataset called the InspAIred dataset. This dataset includes 6,000 posts divided into three groups:
- 2,000 inspiring posts written by Real people.
- 2,000 posts that are not inspiring.
- 2,000 inspiring posts created using AI.
These posts represent two different cultures: India and the UK. The real posts were collected from a platform called Reddit, while the machine-generated posts were made using a popular AI language model.
Data Collection Process
We collected the real inspiring posts from Reddit by searching through specific topics that focus on inspiration and motivation. For India, we targeted various regions, including Kerala and Tamil Nadu, to understand local insights. In the UK, we looked at different areas as well.
After collecting these posts, we used some technology tools to help classify whether a post was inspiring or not. A group of people then reviewed these posts to confirm if they were inspiring based on their personal judgment.
Machine-Generated Content
We generated the AI-inspired posts with a language model that creates human-like text. The model was instructed to write posts that reflect what inspires people from India and the UK.
To ensure quality, we checked a sample of these AI-generated posts to see if they matched well with the inspiring topics we gathered from real users. We wanted to make sure the AI posts had relevant and meaningful content.
Analyzing Inspiring Content
Linguistic Style and Structure
We began our analysis by comparing the language and structure of inspiring posts written by real people to those created by AI. For this analysis, we looked at several factors, including:
- Complexity of Writing: We assessed how sophisticated the writing was, which can indicate deeper thinking.
- Descriptiveness: We checked how many descriptive words were used, as texts with many adjectives often tell a richer story.
- Readability: We evaluated how easy or hard it was to read the posts, considering both the length of the words and the sentences.
The results showed that AI-generated posts are often more complex and descriptive than those written by humans. However, real inspiring posts had their own unique qualities, especially when looking at how people expressed their feelings and ideas.
Understanding Topics in Posts
Next, we explored what topics were most common in inspiring posts. We categorized the posts based on the themes they presented. For instance, in India, discussions often focused on personal experiences, achievements, and Cultural aspects. On the other hand, the UK posts emphasized themes like work, resilience, and personal growth.
We used visual tools to represent how these topics appeared across different posts. This helped us better understand what types of content resonate with different audiences.
The Emotional and Cognitive Aspect of Inspiration
Inspiration is not just about the words used; it also touches people's emotions and thoughts. We used a text analysis tool to look at various emotional markers in the posts, categorizing words related to feelings, social connections, and cognitive processes.
Findings in Indian vs. UK Posts
In inspiring posts from India, we found a stronger connection to family and social ties, while UK posts showed a focus on personal achievements and self-improvement. This indicated that cultural contexts significantly impact how inspiration is expressed and perceived.
Comparing Real and AI-Generated Posts
When comparing real inspiring posts to those generated by AI, we noted some differences in emotional expression. Real posts often included more personal stories and social interactions, while AI posts might have had a wider range of vocabulary but lacked personal touch in some cases.
Can Machines Detect Inspiration?
With our dataset, we also wanted to know if machines could effectively identify inspiring content. We trained a machine learning model using the posts we collected. This model aimed to classify content as inspiring or not, and distinguish between posts from different cultures and sources (real vs. AI).
Training the Model
We used our dataset to train the machine learning model to recognize patterns in inspiring content. The model was trained on a mix of posts, allowing it to learn from both real and AI-generated examples.
Results of Machine Detection
The results showed that the model was quite good at identifying inspiring posts, even with a limited amount of training data. It could accurately distinguish between real and AI content across cultures. This finding suggests that with the right tools, machines can help in recognizing and categorizing inspiring material from various sources.
Implications of the Study
Applications in Daily Life
The insights from this study can be applied in many areas. For instance, social media platforms can highlight more inspiring content to users, improving their online experience and mental well-being.
Contribution to Academic Research
By introducing the InspAIred dataset, we provided resources for further research into inspiration across different cultures. This dataset could be used by other researchers to better understand human emotions and creativity.
Conclusion
In summary, this study explores the concept of inspiration in social media posts across India and the UK. Through the InspAIred dataset, we were able to analyze both real and AI-generated content, examining linguistic styles, emotional connections, and cultural insights. Our findings reveal important differences in how inspiration is expressed and perceived in different cultures. Moreover, the success of machine learning models in detecting inspiring content offers exciting opportunities for future studies and practical applications.
Overall, understanding what inspires us can lead to improved creativity, motivation, and ultimately, a happier life.
Title: Cross-cultural Inspiration Detection and Analysis in Real and LLM-generated Social Media Data
Abstract: Inspiration is linked to various positive outcomes, such as increased creativity, productivity, and happiness. Although inspiration has great potential, there has been limited effort toward identifying content that is inspiring, as opposed to just engaging or positive. Additionally, most research has concentrated on Western data, with little attention paid to other cultures. This work is the first to study cross-cultural inspiration through machine learning methods. We aim to identify and analyze real and AI-generated cross-cultural inspiring posts. To this end, we compile and make publicly available the InspAIred dataset, which consists of 2,000 real inspiring posts, 2,000 real non-inspiring posts, and 2,000 generated inspiring posts evenly distributed across India and the UK. The real posts are sourced from Reddit, while the generated posts are created using the GPT-4 model. Using this dataset, we conduct extensive computational linguistic analyses to (1) compare inspiring content across cultures, (2) compare AI-generated inspiring posts to real inspiring posts, and (3) determine if detection models can accurately distinguish between inspiring content across cultures and data sources.
Authors: Oana Ignat, Gayathri Ganesh Lakshmy, Rada Mihalcea
Last Update: 2024-06-18 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12933
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12933
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.
Reference Links
- https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/LaTeX/Colors
- https://mirrors.ibiblio.org/CTAN/fonts/fontawesome/doc/fontawesome.pdf
- https://ctan.org/pkg/amssymb
- https://ctan.org/pkg/pifont
- https://huggingface.co/FacebookAI/xlm-roberta-base
- https://huggingface.co/textdetox/xlmr-large-toxicity-classifier
- https://huggingface.co/facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target
- https://github.com/snguyenthanh/better_profanity
- https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/text-generation/chat-completions-api
- https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7042661-chatgpt-api-transition-guide
- https://spacy.io/models
- https://anonymous.4open.science/r/cross_inspiration
- https://github.com/MichiganNLP/cross_inspiration