The Hidden Dangers of Freezing Water
Ice can cause unexpected damage in containers during winter.
Menno Demmenie, Paul Kolpakov, Boaz van Casteren, Dirk Bakker, Daniel Bonn, Noushine Shahidzadeh
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- The Freezing Experiment
- Why Does This Matter?
- Looking Deeper
- Watching the Freezing Process
- How to Avoid Breakage
- The Role of Temperature
- Observing the Freezing Dynamics
- Different Types of Containers
- Understanding the Pressure Buildup
- The Importance of Hydrophobic Coatings
- Conclusion: Tips for Avoiding Freezer Catastrophes
- Original Source
During winter, Water's Freezing powers can cause all sorts of trouble for materials. Believe it or not, ICE can break Glass, crack concrete, and ruin your favorite container of juice. This happens even if the water isn't full, yet the ice still finds a clever way to wreak havoc.
The Freezing Experiment
To understand how this works, scientists did freezing tests using cylindrical glass vials. They filled these vials with varying amounts of water while also using a dye to help visualize the freezing. The dye colored the liquid only, making it easier to see where the ice was forming. This nifty little trick allowed the scientists to watch ice form and grow.
What they found was surprising: damage can happen if ice traps a little pocket of liquid water inside it as it freezes. When this hidden water turns to ice, it expands, creating huge pressure. This pressure can easily break both the glass vial and the surrounding ice. Overall, the pressure from crystallization doesn't depend on how much liquid is locked in there, which is a bit wild!
Why Does This Matter?
Most of us have been there, right? You forget a bottle of soda in the freezer, and it explodes into a fizzy mess. Ice formation in tight spots is a real headache for many industries, like construction, farming, and even art preservation.
The common belief is that ice expands when it freezes, and this expansion causes damage. While that makes sense, it doesn’t explain everything. For instance, ice can cause damage even if there’s room to expand. Think about a half-full bottle of water-there should be enough space for the ice to grow without breaking anything. But somehow, it still cracks.
Looking Deeper
To get to the bottom of things, researchers have been studying the first stages of ice formation in small water droplets. They also looked at how special surfaces can delay freezing or promote messy ice formations. However, most of this research looks at tiny drops and doesn’t tell the whole story about ice damage on a larger scale.
Watching the Freezing Process
To truly understand what’s going on, scientists observed key moments in freezing at a chilly temperature. They noted where ice starts forming and how it grows. By taking a lot of pictures quickly, they could see how quickly ice forms and how it interacts with the glass. They even figured the speed of ice formation, which matched previous studies.
Experimenting with different sizes and types of glass vials showed how important it is to control the environment. The results clearly pointed out that trapped water inside growing ice is a major cause of damage. If the ice starts forming at the edge of a water-meniscus (the curve at the top of the water), it can freeze before the rest of the water, trapping liquid in the ice.
How to Avoid Breakage
Interestingly, treating the glass to make it less water-friendly helps a lot. A hydrophobic treatment flattens the meniscus, which pushes the starting point of ice formation down. This means less chance of a liquid pocket forming in the ice, which can prevent damage.
The Role of Temperature
Temperature plays a big role too. When cooling ice from the outside, it can freeze in stages. First, there’s fast dendritic growth (think of ice forming in weird shapes), and then there's a bulk ice formation. If the first stage happens, you might trap more air bubbles inside the ice. These bubbles can act like stress relievers, helping reduce the chance of breaking.
Observing the Freezing Dynamics
In experiments with two groups of glass containers, the researchers saw a big difference in how freezing affected them. One group cooled down in a normal way while the other was supercooled. When the meniscus froze completely, the trapped water became ice, and that’s when fractures began to appear.
They tracked how the ice front moved during the freezing process to learn more about the liquid inclusion formation. This was done by observing how the liquid trapped by the ice shrinks over time. The researchers noted that when the ice cracked, it was often preceded by a large pressure build-up, leading to a sudden drop in stress once the glass container broke.
Different Types of Containers
The type of glass played a part too. For example, the hardness of the glass helps it withstand Pressures better than ice itself. In the experiments, fractures in the ice often appeared before any damage to the glass.
Another interesting thing was how the shape of the vessel affected everything. Smaller containers led to more dendritic growth because of their higher surface-to-volume ratio, leading to more chaotic ice formations.
Understanding the Pressure Buildup
In order to understand the pressures involved, scientists referenced older research about melting and crystallization. When ice freezes, it can create pressures high enough to break glass, a real danger in constricted spaces. Previous works help explain why things break so easily and point to the relationship between pressure and volume changes.
The Importance of Hydrophobic Coatings
Scientists also experimented with treating glass surfaces to see if it would help. Using hydrophobic coatings significantly reduced the chances of liquid inclusion forming, meaning fewer risks of breakage. This simple trick of changing the surface can save your favorite drink from meeting a frosty end in your freezer.
Conclusion: Tips for Avoiding Freezer Catastrophes
So, what can we learn from all of this? If you want to avoid freezer disasters, you might want to use smaller glass containers and make sure they are hydrophobic. The smaller size helps limit ice formation, and the coatings keep crystal growth in check.
In short, while freezing water seems harmless, it can lead to surprises, especially if you're not paying attention. Every time winter rolls around, it’s good to remember that our favorite liquids can turn into damaging ice if we’re not careful. Just keep your bottles in check, and maybe, just maybe, your juice will stay intact!
Title: Damage due to Ice Crystallization
Abstract: The freezing of water is one of the major causes of mechanical damage in materials during wintertime; surprisingly this happens even in situations where water only partially saturates the material so that the ice has room to grow. Here we perform freezing experiments in cylindrical glass vials of various sizes and wettability properties, using a dye that exclusively colors the liquid phase; this allows to precisely observe the freezing front. The visualization reveals that damage occurs in partially water-saturated media when a closed liquid inclusion forms within the ice due to the freezing of air/water meniscus. When this water inclusion subsequently freezes, the volume expansion leads to very high pressures leading to the fracture of both the surrounding ice and the glass vial. The pressure can be understood quantitatively based on thermodynamics which correctly predicts that the crystallization pressure is independent of the volume of the liquid pocket. Finally, our results also reveal that by changing the wetting properties of the confining walls, the formation of the liquid pockets that cause the mechanical damage can be avoided.
Authors: Menno Demmenie, Paul Kolpakov, Boaz van Casteren, Dirk Bakker, Daniel Bonn, Noushine Shahidzadeh
Last Update: 2024-11-11 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04670
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.04670
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.