The Risks of Rhythmic Gymnastics Training
Intense training and body image issues affect young female athletes.
Kayo Yoshitani-Kuwabara, Yukina Yumen, Yumi Takayama, Natsuho Kitayama, Fumiaki Hanzawa, Naoki Sakane, Narumi Nagai
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- What Is Low Energy Availability?
- Who Is Affected?
- Why Do Rhythm Gymnasts Experience This?
- Comparing Rhythmic Gymnasts to Other Athletes
- Who Took Part in the Study?
- How Was Data Collected?
- What Did the Study Find?
- Participant Characteristics
- How Common Is FAT?
- Body Image and Eating Habits
- What’s Behind All This?
- The Bigger Picture
- Conclusion
- Original Source
Many young women are getting into sports, which is great! But with intensive training and the pressure to lose weight, some can face serious health issues. One of these is known as the female athlete triad (FAT). This fancy term describes a trio of problems: not getting enough energy (low energy availability), messed-up menstrual cycles, and weak bones. These problems can start when young women push their bodies too hard while not eating enough to keep up with their energy needs.
What Is Low Energy Availability?
Low energy availability (LEA) means that athletes are burning more calories than they eat. When this happens, their bodies can’t keep up. It can lead to menstrual dysfunction (MD), which is when their periods become irregular or stop altogether. It can also affect bone health, which is really important, especially for young women still growing.
Who Is Affected?
Some sports are riskier than others when it comes to FAT. For example, rhythmic gymnastics and figure skating tend to have a higher number of athletes dealing with these issues. In Japan, there are about 10,000 young female rhythmic gymnasts, many of whom start training in elementary school and continue through high school and beyond.
Studies show that rhythmic gymnasts often have higher rates of not having their periods (amenorrhea) compared to athletes in sports like volleyball or soccer. While around 41% of rhythmic gymnasts face this issue, only about 6% of volleyball players and less than 4% of soccer players do. The same goes for stress fractures; rhythmic gymnasts also have higher rates than athletes in non-aesthetic sports.
Why Do Rhythm Gymnasts Experience This?
Rhythmic gymnastics is all about looking graceful and, often, being really thin. This can lead young athletes to cut back on what they eat to meet those standards. Unfortunately, this can lead to LEA, which might mess up their periods and make their bones weaker. To help these young athletes, it's really important to spot the signs of FAT early on.
Research shows that the desire to lose weight is often tied to a skewed idea of Body Image. Many young women, including rhythmic gymnasts, may think they should be thinner than they actually need to be, which can make them feel unhappy and chase extreme weight loss. By looking into the link between the desire to lose weight and body image in these athletes, we might be able to tackle the issue before it gets out of hand.
Comparing Rhythmic Gymnasts to Other Athletes
To understand the body image and eating habits of rhythmic gymnasts better, researchers compared them with female volleyball players and non-athletes of similar age. High school and university students were chosen for this study because, by this age, most have stabilized menstrual cycles and are close to being fully grown.
The goal was to figure out what drives FAT and body image issues in rhythmic gymnasts compared to their peers. This study involved a survey where participants answered questions about their health, eating habits, body image, and any signs of FAT.
Who Took Part in the Study?
In this study, female high school and university students were asked to participate. There were three groups:
- Rhythmic gymnasts (40 participants)
- Volleyball players (46 participants)
- Non-athlete female students (108 participants)
The rhythmic gymnasts were competitive and practicing daily. The volleyball players were also highly competitive. Non-athletes were students from local universities and were included to give a comparison group. Everyone had to agree to take the survey, and written consent was gathered.
How Was Data Collected?
Participants completed a self-report questionnaire through Google Forms that covered a range of topics. They shared their basic characteristics such as age, height, weight, and how long they had been playing their sport. They also reported on their menstrual health and any history of stress fractures.
To assess body image, participants picked from different body silhouettes to indicate how they saw themselves and what they thought was ideal. Any differences between how they viewed themselves and their actual body size were noted as body image distortion.
Eating habits were also examined through a survey. Participants answered questions that helped gauge their attitudes toward food and any unusual eating patterns. For instance, those who skipped meals or frequently weighed themselves were flagged as having potentially unhealthy behaviors.
What Did the Study Find?
Participant Characteristics
The study showed that rhythmic gymnasts were generally shorter and lighter than volleyball players and non-athletes. Their body mass index (BMI), which helps measure weight relative to height, was also lower. This might sound like a trophy, but it’s not a healthy badge when it comes to performance and overall well-being.
How Common Is FAT?
When looking at the prevalence of FAT among the three groups, it became clear that rhythmic gymnasts had more problems with LEA and menstrual dysfunction compared to volleyball players and non-athletes. Over half of the rhythmic gymnasts were classified as having LEA, while only a small number of volleyball players and non-athletes were in the same boat.
Body Image and Eating Habits
Distorted body image was also more common among rhythmic gymnasts. Many thought they should be much thinner than they are. A whopping 55% of rhythmic gymnasts overestimated their body shape compared to just 6.5% of volleyball players. This can lead to unhealthy habits, like frequent weighing and calorie restriction.
For eating behaviors, rhythmic gymnasts scored higher on tests that measured tendencies toward Eating Disorders. More of them reported skipping breakfast regularly compared to non-athletes. They were also more likely to see their food intake as excessive.
What’s Behind All This?
The study found that the pressures faced by rhythmic gymnasts, combined with a skewed view of their body shape, are significant contributors to FAT. They train hard and want to maintain a certain look, which often leads to unhealthy eating behaviors.
The Bigger Picture
While this study focused on rhythmic gymnasts, the lessons learned can apply to other sports, especially those emphasizing appearance. It highlights the need for support and education to promote healthy eating habits and a positive body image among young female athletes.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while sports can be a fantastic outlet for young women, there are risks involved, especially in appearance-focused sports like rhythmic gymnastics. Young athletes are caught in a cycle of trying to meet unrealistic standards, leading to serious health consequences. It's crucial to address these issues now so they don’t become lifelong struggles.
Let’s look out for these young athletes and help them find a balance in their training and personal health. Because, in the end, winning isn’t everything-staying healthy and happy is the real goal.
Title: Prevalence of female athlete triad (FAT) in rhythmic gymnastics, an aesthetic sport, and its association with risks of body-image distortion and eating disorders
Abstract: BackgroundFemale athlete triad (FAT), a syndrome linking low energy availability (LEA), menstrual dysfunction (MD), and impaired bone health, has serious potential consequences for sports performance and health. In this cross-sectional study, we investigated prevalences of each FAT component in female athletes of aesthetic and non-aesthetic sports and in non-athlete females, and its association with body image (BI) distortion and eating behaviors. MethodsGoogle Forms was used to examine self-reported height and weight, menstruation conditions, history of stress fractures (HSF), BI, the Eating Attitude Test (EAT)-26 (indicator of eating disorder) scores, and eating behaviors; these attributes were compared between 3 groups (athletes of aesthetic sports [rhythmic gymnasts, n=40] and non-esthetic sports [volleyball players, n=46]; other females of the same age group [non-athletes, n=108]). To identify risk factors for each FAT component, multivariate logistic-regression analyses were used. LEA, MD, and HSF were dependent variables; rhythmic gymnasts, distorted BI, and EAT-26 scores were independent variables. ResultsRhythmic gymnasts had a lower body mass index (p
Authors: Kayo Yoshitani-Kuwabara, Yukina Yumen, Yumi Takayama, Natsuho Kitayama, Fumiaki Hanzawa, Naoki Sakane, Narumi Nagai
Last Update: Oct 30, 2024
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.10.29.24316350
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.10.29.24316350.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.