Sci Simple

New Science Research Articles Everyday

# Biology # Evolutionary Biology

The Colorful Secrets of Speyeria Mormonia

Discover the intriguing color variations of butterflies in nature.

Luca Livraghi, Joseph J. Hanly, Ling Sheng Loh, Albie Henry, Chloe M.T. Keck, Vaughn M. Shirey, Cheng-Chia Tsai, Nanfang Yu, Steven M. Van Belleghem, W. Mark Roberts, Carol L. Boggs, Arnaud Martin

― 6 min read


Secrets of Butterfly Secrets of Butterfly Color Variations color and adaptation. Uncover the genetics behind butterfly
Table of Contents

In the world of butterflies, looks can be deceiving. Take the Speyeria mormonia, for example. This butterfly displays two different color patterns on its hindwings, which are the Silver and unsilvered morphs. While one version glimmers with iridescent silver scales, the other is adorned with light beige spots. This unique feature sparks curiosity about how and why these butterflies have such varying appearances.

What Are Silver and Unsilvered Morphs?

Imagine seeing two butterflies that look almost the same at first glance. One has bright silver scales shining in the sunlight while the other has a more muted, beige appearance. These are known as silver and unsilvered morphs. The difference lies in the tiny scales on their wings. Unsilvered morphs have scales that are a bit pigmented and porous, which absorb light. In contrast, silver scales are unpigmented and reflect light, creating a shiny appearance.

Geographic Distribution and Variation

Speyeria mormonia is not picky when it comes to its home. It can be found across mountainous areas in western North America. But here’s the kicker: the frequency of silver and unsilvered morphs varies from one location to another. Some regions are buzzing with silver morphs, while others have a distinct shortage of them. A study looked at nearly 10,000 records of these butterflies and found that as you move north, silver morphs become less common. This leads to a fascinating realization: butterflies might be influenced by their local environment in ways we don’t fully understand.

In southeastern Oregon and northern Nevada, for instance, unsilvered morphs are quite popular, while nearby areas see fewer of them. This suggests that butterflies in certain habitats are doing their own thing, irrespective of the larger population trends. Scientists attempted to connect these morph frequencies to environmental factors like sunlight and temperature, but the associations were surprisingly weak. It seems that local conditions or unique population dynamics have a significant role in these butterflies' appearances.

The Genetics Behind the Shine

Sexier than a football club's transfer rumors: the genetic inheritance of silvering in these butterflies is dominated by simple rules. The silver trait is a rare, recessive trait, which means you need two copies of the silver gene to see the sparkle. Scientists conducted controlled breeding experiments, which led to the realization that the silvering is connected to a single location on chromosome 14.

By examining the Genes of these butterflies, researchers identified a specific section of DNA that correlates with the presence of silver scales. This section lies near a gene called optix, which is known for its role in butterfly color and patterning. More specifically, it affects how butterflies develop their wing scales. The magic happens when the silver morphs have SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms) that differ from the unsilvered ones. Think of these SNPs as tiny switches that control the color factory in the wing scales.

Optix: The Butterfly's Master Switch

Now, let’s talk about optix. This gene is the superstar of butterfly wing patterns. It’s like the director in a fashion show, making sure everything looks just right. When optix is active, it helps produce certain pigments that lead to vibrant colors. Surprisingly, it also prevents the formation of silver scales. In unsilvered morphs, the optix gene appears to be doing its job more effectively, allowing for those beautiful beige spots to shine through instead of silver.

In simple terms, if optix were to take a vacation, the silver scales would take over the stage. This means that the gene is not just responsible for adding color but also for limiting other colors or patterns.

The Role of Environment and Evolution

The varying frequencies of silver and unsilvered morphs in different regions hint at some evolutionary drama. It seems there are forces at play that maintain this genetic variety. In certain areas like the Cascade and Klamath Mountains, the recessive silver state is almost the star of the show, while other populations feature a mix of both silver and unsilvered morphs.

Research suggests that the unsilvered allele shows signs of “selective sweeps,” which means it has a genetic advantage in some environments. In simpler terms, it's like seeing one team consistently winning in a sport. Scientists checked the optix gene for signs of these selective sweeps and found them in populations where unsilvered morphs are common.

The Mystery of Introgression

But wait, there’s more! It turns out Speyeria mormonia is not the only butterfly in town. It shares its habitats with related species, like Speyeria hydaspe, which only sports the unsilvered look. Occasionally, these butterflies mix it up and produce hybrids. This might lead to some unsilvered Alleles making their way into the Speyeria mormonia gene pool.

Researchers used a fancy test to check if these butterflies were sharing their genes. To their delight, they found evidence of gene flow between S. mormonia and S. hydaspe. Think of it as butterflies exchanging beauty tips—unsilvered alleles were sneaking into the S. mormonia population, boosting their unsilvered frequencies.

The Big Picture: Adaptation and Evolution Repeatability

What’s the takeaway from all this butterfly drama? The genetics behind adaptation can be surprisingly predictable. The story of the optix gene does not just stop with S. mormonia. Other butterfly lineages have also shown that changes in this same gene lead to variation in color patterns.

It’s like a popular song getting covered by multiple artists in different styles. While the genres might change, the underlying melody remains the same. In this case, optix is the catchy tune that leads to various beautiful effects.

Now, researchers are left wondering how often this happens in nature. Do similar genes keep popping up to create new colors and patterns in different species? The answer might just be yes.

The Unanswered Questions

Despite all the discoveries, there are still some mysteries left to unravel. For instance, what role do silver and unsilvered spots play in the everyday life of these butterflies? Are they used for flirting, or are they simply for camouflage? More research is needed to understand the ecological functions of wing patterns and how they interact with predators and mates.

Conclusion

In the grand scheme of things, the tale of Speyeria mormonia and its silver polymorphism adds another layer to our understanding of butterfly evolution. It’s a vibrant dance of genetics, environment, and adaptation. While these butterflies may look delicate, their story is anything but simple. Who knew that such colorful creatures carried within them a saga of survival and change?

And the next time you spot a butterfly flitting by, take a moment to appreciate not just its beauty but also the complexity behind those dazzling wings. After all, in the world of butterflies, it’s not just about looking good but also playing the evolutionary game splendidly!

Original Source

Title: Genetic basis of an adaptive polymorphism controlling butterfly silver iridescence

Abstract: Identifying the genes and mutations that drive phenotypic variation and which are subject to selection is crucial for understanding evolutionary processes. Mormon Fritillary butterflies (Speyeria mormonia) exhibit a striking wing color polymorphism throughout their range: typical morphs bear silver spots on their ventral surfaces, and can co-occur with unsilvered morphs displaying a dull coloration1. Through genome-wide association studies in two polymorphic populations, we fine-map this difference in silvering to the 3 region of the transcription factor gene optix. The expression of optix is confined to the unsilvered regions that surround the spots, and these patterns are transformed to a silver identity upon optix RNAi knockdown, implicating optix as a repressor of silver scales in this butterfly. We show that the unsilvered optix haplotype shows signatures of recent selective sweeps, and that this allele is shared with the monomorphic, unsilvered species Speyeria hydaspe, suggesting that introgressions facilitate the exchange of variants of adaptive potential across species. Remarkably, these findings parallel the role of introgressions and cis-regulatory modulation of optix in shaping the aposematic red patterns of Heliconius butterflies2-7, a lineage that separated from Speyeria 45 million years ago8. The genetic basis of adaptive variation can thus be more predictable than often presumed, even for traits that appear divergent across large evolutionary distances. O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=199 SRC="FIGDIR/small/628425v1_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (112K): [email protected]@982c74org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@8e90b3org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1bddf3c_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG Graphical Abstract C_FIG

Authors: Luca Livraghi, Joseph J. Hanly, Ling Sheng Loh, Albie Henry, Chloe M.T. Keck, Vaughn M. Shirey, Cheng-Chia Tsai, Nanfang Yu, Steven M. Van Belleghem, W. Mark Roberts, Carol L. Boggs, Arnaud Martin

Last Update: 2024-12-17 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.13.628425

Source PDF: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.13.628425.full.pdf

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to biorxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

Similar Articles