Crisis in Gaza: The Fight Against Malnutrition
A look at the escalating food crisis and its impact on children's health in Gaza.
Francesco Checchi, Zeina Jamaluddine
― 8 min read
Table of Contents
- Food Security in Gaza
- Malnutrition: A Growing Concern
- The Importance of Caloric Intake
- Population and Analysis Period
- How the Model Works
- Estimating Pre-War Growth Patterns
- Weight Changes in Crisis Conditions
- Family Food Practices in Crisis
- Impact of Illness on Nutrition
- Challenges for New Mothers
- Treatment of Malnutrition
- Data Sources Used in the Model
- Scenario Projections
- Model Testing and Validation
- Observations and Findings
- Main Takeaways
- Future Enhancements
- Conclusion
- Original Source
- Reference Links
Since October 2023, the Gaza Strip has been in the midst of a serious humanitarian crisis, marked by heavy military actions and strict restrictions on the movement of people and goods. This situation led to a significant decline in food availability, raising concerns about food insecurity for many residents. For the first several months of the conflict, reports highlighted a dire lack of food, particularly in northern areas like Gaza City and North Gaza. Sadly, there were even tragic accounts of people suffering from starvation.
Food Security in Gaza
In the early months of the crisis, reduced food deliveries meant that many families were struggling to find enough to eat. Various reports from the media and community organizations pointed to widespread Food Shortages, especially in the northern governorates. As the situation persisted, warnings of potential famine grew stronger. However, starting in April 2024, there appeared to be a slight improvement in Food Access when border crossings were reopened, allowing more food to flow into the area. Unfortunately, accurate data about food supplies became difficult to obtain when Israel took control of key customs points, limiting the United Nations' ability to track incoming food deliveries.
Malnutrition: A Growing Concern
Malnutrition, especially Acute Malnutrition among children and pregnant or nursing women, has become a major issue in Gaza. This form of malnutrition often arises due to a lack of adequate food intake. During crises, it tends to hit the youngest and most vulnerable the hardest. To assess the situation, health workers typically conduct surveys that measure children's growth, classifying them based on their weight and height. However, ongoing insecurity in Gaza made these surveys challenging. Instead, health teams had to rely on quicker community screenings, which, while useful, do not provide as detailed or accurate a picture of malnutrition as the traditional methods.
The Importance of Caloric Intake
Recent research in Gaza focused on estimating the amount of food available over time and its impact on children's health. A new framework was introduced that uses mathematical modeling to estimate how many children are likely to suffer from acute malnutrition based on the amount of food available. This model takes into account various protective or risky factors, such as existing malnutrition treatments, common illnesses affecting children, and the sharing of food within families—a coping strategy where adults may eat less so their children can eat more.
Population and Analysis Period
Gaza was divided into two regions for analysis: the northern region, which includes North Gaza and Gaza City, and the south-central region, which includes areas like Khan Younis and Rafah. Before the conflict began, there were around 1.2 million people living in northern Gaza. By March 2024, that number had dropped to about 250,000, reflecting the intense impact of the crisis.
The analysis looked back from October 2023 to May 2024, marking a period when food monitoring became increasingly difficult due to the conflict. The research also projected future scenarios from May to December 2024 based on food availability and other related factors.
How the Model Works
The model used in this research simulates a group of children aged 0 to 59 months old over daily time periods. Each child in the model is assigned random characteristics like age, sex, height, and weight based on what is expected in a non-crisis setting. The model then tracks how these children would grow over time under different food availability scenarios, including the impact of adults sacrificing their own food for their children and the incidence of illnesses that could reduce food intake.
As children ‘age out’ of the model, newborns are added to maintain the total population, and the model does not account for mortality, assuming the population size stays stable.
Estimating Pre-War Growth Patterns
Before the conflict, health organizations in Gaza conducted routine monitoring of children’s growth. They collected millions of weight and height measurements over a few years to establish normal growth patterns. This data helped create a baseline to understand how children would have grown if the crisis had not occurred. The model assumes that children would remain at their growth percentile if the pre-war conditions continued. This means that children at a higher weight percentile would typically stay in that range unless something changed drastically.
Weight Changes in Crisis Conditions
To understand how children’s weight changes based on food intake, researchers used a previously developed model. This model predicts how much weight children gain or lose based on the calories they consume and their energy expenditure, which includes daily activities, growth, and other factors. This approach helps estimate how many children are likely to experience malnutrition by tracking their expected weight changes based on caloric intake.
Family Food Practices in Crisis
During times of food shortages, it is common for adults in families to give up some of their food for their children. This study assumed that adults would prioritize their children’s nutritional needs above their own, especially in dire circumstances. To estimate how this practice impacts children’s caloric intake, researchers simulated various households with different sizes and compositions, exploring how much food adults might sacrifice to feed their kids.
Impact of Illness on Nutrition
Illness can significantly affect a child's ability to consume enough calories. The model accounted for common infectious diseases that could reduce how much food children are able to eat during illness episodes. By studying various research papers, researchers found patterns in how illness impacts food intake and incorporated these findings into the model to better understand the interplay between health and nutrition.
Challenges for New Mothers
The model also recognized the challenges faced by new mothers and infants, particularly concerning breastfeeding practices. In a crisis, many infants may not exclusively be breastfed, which can affect their caloric intake. The model factored in these challenges, based on existing data about feeding practices in the region.
Treatment of Malnutrition
Treating malnutrition, especially severe cases, often involves outpatient care where children receive extra calories. For children with severe acute malnutrition (SAM), treatment includes high-calorie food to help them recover. The model incorporated this treatment process and assumed that children needing treatment would indeed receive care, though it acknowledged potential delays in accessing these services.
Data Sources Used in the Model
To feed the model, researchers gathered various data points regarding food intake, malnutrition treatments, and the overall health of children. This included recommendations for calories based on age and sex, along with actual intake estimates derived from earlier studies.
Scenario Projections
The researchers established several scenarios to project potential outcomes for malnutrition rates in Gaza. These scenarios range from a central prediction of food availability to "best case" and "worst case" scenarios, considering different levels of food intake and treatment coverage. This helps visualize how changing situations might lead to varying degrees of malnutrition among children.
Model Testing and Validation
To ensure the model's accuracy, researchers compared its predictions against existing data on children’s growth patterns in Gaza. They found reasonable agreement, although the model sometimes underestimated variability in nutrition status. Over time, it became clear that the model accurately reflected expected growth patterns under normal circumstances.
Observations and Findings
The research highlighted that acute malnutrition peaked in early 2024, largely driven by food scarcity during the conflict. By May, the situation showed signs of improvement as food became more accessible. However, projections suggested that without adequate support and continued access to food, serious malnutrition could return to both northern and southern regions of Gaza.
Main Takeaways
This study marks an important step in developing a model to predict malnutrition based on food availability and numerous factors affecting children's health. The findings reinforced the idea that adult sacrifice plays a crucial role in child nutrition during crises. The model provides insights into how food shortages can dramatically influence nutrition, especially among vulnerable populations. Additionally, it serves to assist in planning interventions aimed at supporting child health in crises.
Future Enhancements
While the model showed promise, it also highlighted areas needing improvement. Future versions could better account for food distribution inequities and the dynamic nature of adult sacrifice. It also should include more about how infections can worsen malnutrition and pay closer attention to experiences unique to infants and new mothers.
Conclusion
The situation in Gaza remains critical, with food access and nutritional stability deeply intertwined. This ongoing research underscores the importance of quickly assessing food availability and malnutrition to inform humanitarian responses. The model provides a tool to help stakeholders understand potential future scenarios, which can support planning for critical interventions and ensure children's health is prioritized in challenging times. With the right data and continued efforts, the hope is to combat the rising tide of malnutrition in Gaza and support the well-being of its youngest and most vulnerable residents.
In conclusion, while the crisis may seem daunting, understanding the situation is the first step towards making a difference—because nobody wants to see kids go to bed hungry. After all, a full stomach is a happy stomach, and a happy stomach leads to happier families.
Original Source
Title: Evolution of child acute malnutrition during war in the Gaza Strip, 2023-2024: retrospective estimates and scenario-based projections
Abstract: BackgroundNutritional status has been compromised by ongoing war and restrictions on food deliveries in the Gaza Strip. We developed a mathematical model that outputs retrospective estimates and scenario-based projections of acute malnutrition prevalence among children given caloric intake and other factors. We present here the model and its application to the crisis in Gaza. MethodsWe extended an existing mechanistic model for weight change as a function of energy balance, calibrating it to represent variability in growth curves observed in pre-war Gaza. We simulated open cohorts of children exposed to time-varying caloric intake, infant exclusive breastfeeding prevalence, incidence of infectious disease and coverage of malnutrition treatment, while allowing for adult caloric sacrifice to supplement child intake in times of food scarcity. Results and conclusionsThe model accurately replicates growth standards, pre-war growth patterns and expected parameter dependencies. It suggests that a considerable increase in acute malnutrition occurred in northern Gaza during early 2024. Projections for late 2024 include a serious nutritional emergency if relatively pessimistic assumptions are made about food availability. The model may hold considerable promise for informing decisions in humanitarian response but requires further validation and development.
Authors: Francesco Checchi, Zeina Jamaluddine
Last Update: 2024-12-11 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.10.24318783
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.10.24318783.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.