Sci Simple

New Science Research Articles Everyday

# Health Sciences # Infectious Diseases (except HIV/AIDS)

Wastewater Surveillance: Tracking Hidden Variants

Scientists use wastewater to uncover hidden virus lineages and mutations.

Reinier Suarez, Devon A. Gregory, David A. Baker, Clayton Rushford, Torin Hunter, Nicholas R. Minor, Clayton Russ, Emma Copen, David H. O’Connor, Marc C. Johnson

― 7 min read


Tracking Hidden Virus Tracking Hidden Virus Variants lineages and mutations. Wastewater reveals unseen SARS-CoV-2
Table of Contents

Wastewater surveillance has become a go-to method for tracking germs and chemicals in our environment. Think of it as a nosy neighbor peeking into everyone’s backyards—except in this case, it’s scientists looking at the sewage to figure out what’s going on. This method gained popularity during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, allowing experts to keep tabs on various variants of the virus, which is basically like keeping score in a really intense game of tag.

The Cryptic Lineages

In early 2021, researchers in the field started to track the SARS-CoV-2 virus in wastewater. By March of the same year, they found a version of the virus that seemed to have evolved quicker than others. They named this sneaky variant a "cryptic lineage." These cryptic lineages turned out to be like the VIP section of COVID-19 Mutations, often appearing in wastewater but not always recognized in human infections.

As the pandemic unfolded, scientists from various parts of the world began reporting about these stealthy variants. Some studies pointed out similarities between these cryptic lineages and persistent infections in people with weak immune systems. You could say that these cryptic lineages were hiding out in the bodies of those individuals, just chilling, while the rest of the world was frantically dealing with the pandemic.

Interestingly, some of these lineages were traced back to places where the virus had supposedly stopped circulating. For instance, one cryptic lineage was found in a commercial building in late 2022, even though the original lineage had been gone since early 2021. It's like finding a sock in the laundry from last year's wash.

Mutations and Variants

One fascinating thing about cryptic lineages is their ability to hint at future mutations. Think of them as the teaser trailers for the next big movie—the future variants. Some mutations in the virus, like N440K and E484A, were seen in these lineages long before they showed up in more well-known variants like Omicron.

This similarity suggests that cryptic lineages might face similar challenges and pressures as the known circulating variants. Even though many mutations seen in cryptic lineages haven't made it to the mainstream variants yet, the question remains: will they ever see the light of day? It's like asking whether that leftover pizza in the fridge will ever get eaten.

Data Gathering from Wastewater

Governments and organizations around the globe have started using whole genome sequencing (WGS) to keep tabs on SARS-CoV-2 variants in wastewater. This data often makes its way into large databases. Researchers recently examined over 135,000 wastewater samples from more than 2,000 locations across 45 different countries. It’s safe to say they had their hands full.

Using a specific set of mutations, they identified over 20 cryptic lineages. They compiled a detailed list of these mutations and dubbed it the "cryptic lineage-defining amino acid substitutions." This name might sound fancy, but it simply refers to the unique genetic changes found in these sneakier versions of the virus.

Searching for Cryptic Lineages

By using the term “SARS-CoV-2 wastewater,” researchers began downloading sequence data from a public database, aiming to catch these cryptic lineages in the act. They focused on samples collected before October 31, 2023, which means they were looking for the older versions of the virus that might still be lurking in the sewers.

They scrutinized the sequences of identifiable reads that had several of the mutations they were interested in. This meticulous work led to the discovery of 18 independent cryptic lineages. Some had already been reported, while others were new to the game. The length of time these lineages were detected varied greatly, which is like comparing how long a friendship lasts—some might be fleeting, while others stand the test of time.

Comparing Lineages

Once researchers had identified the cryptic lineages based on their sequences, they compared them to data from nearby sewer systems that didn’t have these sneaky variants. By analyzing the unique mutations that appeared more frequently in cryptic lineages, they developed a clearer picture of what was going on. For instance, if a particular mutation was found in a cryptic lineage much more than in neighboring systems, it was tagged as a "cryptic-specific mutation."

This in-depth analysis was repeated across all identified lineages, allowing scientists to piece together the genetic bits that made each lineage unique. It wasn't always easy, as some lineages had more data available than others, but they were determined.

Phylogenetic Trees and Common Ancestry

To visualize their findings, researchers created phylogenetic trees, which are like family trees for viruses. These trees showed the relationships among the cryptic lineages, revealing that they all descended from older versions of the virus that had disappeared long ago.

Interestingly, while mapping out these lineages, scientists noticed that some mutations had appeared in multiple independent lineages. This suggests that these lineages might be responding to common pressures, much like siblings developing similar habits after growing up in the same home.

Convergent Mutations

Among the changes noted, many seemed to pop up in at least three cryptic lineages. Scientists mapped these mutations onto the structure of the virus, highlighting the ones that were common among the sneaky variants. For some reason, two of the most common changes in the Spike protein, K417T and Q493K, seemed to be particularly popular.

K417T was known for helping the virus dodge antibodies and, while it had been around for a bit, it was still rare in the mainstream variants. On the other hand, Q493K was quite the wallflower—rarely seen outside of the cryptic lineages.

Insertions and Duplications

In addition to mutations, researchers also found small insertions in the genomes of some cryptic lineages. Think of these as little unexpected "bonus" features. Some of these insertions came from corresponding sections of the virus's own genome, showing that it borrowed bits and pieces of itself.

It turned out that one cryptic lineage was detected in two different sewer systems, separated by a distance of around 40 miles. This prompted scientists to wonder if a person who traveled between the two locations could be the common source. This was akin to the classic "it takes a village" adage—except in this case, it might take multiple sewer systems to track down the virus.

How It All Fits Together

While tracking down these cryptic lineages is essential, researchers also realized that searching through large databases could underrepresent how common these lineages actually are. The method they used relies heavily on specific changes that these cryptic lineages always seem to have. However, there could be other cryptic lineages lurking about without the same identifiers, ready to spring into action.

Despite the challenges, the team was able to show that this approach effectively detects these lurking variants and identifies their specific mutations. It’s like being on the lookout for a hidden treasure—sometimes you need to dig a little deeper to find what you’re looking for.

The Bigger Picture

The study of cryptic lineages is crucial to understanding how SARS-CoV-2 has evolved. The insertions and mutations discovered in these lineages can hint at how the virus might adapt to different environments, such as the gastrointestinal tract versus respiratory pathways.

One significant finding was that these cryptic lineages seemed to revert to a sequence found in closely related bat viruses. While most of the world views SARS-CoV-2 as primarily a respiratory virus, it appears these cryptic variations are more resilient than previously thought. They might be thriving in areas where you wouldn't expect a virus like this to hang out.

Conclusion

In conclusion, wastewater surveillance is like having a crystal ball that peers into the hidden world of viruses. It allows scientists to understand how SARS-CoV-2 and its sneaky relatives are evolving and adapting. By tracking these cryptic lineages, researchers are better equipped to respond to future variants, making it essential for public health.

So the next time you hear about wastewater surveillance, remember there's more happening beneath the surface than meets the eye. With a little perseverance and a lot of detective work, scientists continue to reveal the secrets of these elusive viruses, one sewer at a time.

Original Source

Title: Detecting SARS-CoV-2 Cryptic Lineages using Publicly Available Whole Genome Wastewater Sequencing Data

Abstract: Beginning in early 2021, unique and highly divergent lineages of SARS-CoV-2 were sporadically found in wastewater sewersheds using a sequencing strategy focused on the most mutagenic region of SARS-CoV-2, the receptor binding domain (RBD). Because these RBD sequences did not match known circulating strains and their source was not known, we termed them "cryptic lineages". To date, more than 20 cryptic lineages have been identified using the RBD-focused sequencing strategy. Here, we identified and characterized additional cryptic lineages from SARS-CoV-2 wastewater sequences submitted to NCBIs Sequence Read Archives (SRA). Wastewater sequence datasets were screened for individual sequence reads that contained combinations of mutations frequently found in cryptic lineages but not contemporary circulating lineages. Using this method, we identified 18 cryptic lineages that appeared in multiple samples from the same sewershed, including 12 that were not previously reported. Partial consensus sequences were generated for each cryptic lineage by extracting and mapping sequences containing cryptic-specific mutations. Surprisingly, seven of the mutations that appeared convergently in cryptic lineages were reversions to sequences that were highly conserved in SARS- CoV-2-related bat Sarbecoviruses. The apparent reversion to bat Sarbecovirus sequences suggests that SARS- CoV-2 adaptation to replicate efficiently in respiratory tissues preceded the COVID-19 pandemic. Author SummaryWastewater surveillance has been used during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic to monitor viral activity and the spread of viral lineages. Occasionally, SARS-CoV-2 sequences from wastewater reveal unique evolutionary advanced lineages of SARS-CoV-2 from an unknown source, which are termed cryptic lineages. Many groups nationwide also use wastewater surveillance to track the virus and upload that information to NCBIs SRA database. That sequence data was screened to identify 18 cryptic lineages worldwide and identify convergent mutations throughout the genome of multiple cryptic lineages that suggest reversion to residues common in SARS-CoV-2-related Sarbecoviruses.

Authors: Reinier Suarez, Devon A. Gregory, David A. Baker, Clayton Rushford, Torin Hunter, Nicholas R. Minor, Clayton Russ, Emma Copen, David H. O’Connor, Marc C. Johnson

Last Update: 2024-12-27 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.24.24319568

Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.24.24319568.full.pdf

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

More from authors

Similar Articles