Revolutionizing Pregnancy Care: Group ANC
Group ANC enhances antenatal care for better outcomes in pregnancy.
Crystal L. Patil, Kathleen F. Norr, Esnath Kapito, Li C. Liu, Xiaohan Mei, Elizabeth T. Abrams, Elizabeth Chodzaza, Genesis Chorwe-Sungani, Ursula Kafulafula, Allissa Desloge, Ashley Gresh, Rohan D. Jeremiah, Dhruvi R. Patel, Anne Batchelder, Heidy Wang, Jocelyn Faydenko, Sharon S. Rising, Ellen Chirwa
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- The Importance of ANC
- Why ANC Often Feels Rushed
- Group ANC: A Better Way to Provide Care
- Key Features of Group ANC
- The Malawi Group ANC Model
- The Study
- Setting and Participants
- How the Study Worked
- Results of the Study
- Knowledge and Behavior Improvements
- Communication and Care Beyond ANC
- Clinical Outcomes
- Limitations and External Challenges
- The Future of Group ANC
- Conclusion
- Original Source
Antenatal Care (ANC) is the health support that pregnant women receive to ensure a healthy pregnancy and safe delivery. It involves regular check-ups, screenings, and education on how to keep both mother and baby healthy. It aims to identify any potential health issues early and provide necessary advice and support.
The Importance of ANC
Receiving good antenatal care can make a big difference in a woman's pregnancy experience. It saves lives by ensuring health problems are caught early and addressed. Pregnant women who go through sufficient ANC have better outcomes for themselves and their babies. Unfortunately, in low- and middle-income countries, only about half of pregnant women get the level of care they need. This situation is concerning since many of these women truly value the support ANC can offer.
Why ANC Often Feels Rushed
Many women report that their visits can feel hurried and impersonal. Long wait times for care can make the experience frustrating. Health promotion often consists of general lectures without much room for discussion. In short, even though women appreciate ANC, their experiences often leave much to be desired.
Group ANC: A Better Way to Provide Care
Enter Group ANC, an innovative approach that seeks to improve the quality of care. Instead of individual appointments, a small group of women at similar stages of pregnancy meet together. They are guided by a trained provider and a co-facilitator. This method addresses many common issues of traditional ANC, such as long waits and limited interaction with care providers.
In Group ANC, after an individual intake visit, the women gather for their appointments. These group sessions last significantly longer—around 1.5 to 2 hours compared to the usual 10-20 minutes for individual visits. The format encourages interaction and support, making the experience more engaging and enjoyable.
Key Features of Group ANC
Group ANC has three main components that improve the pregnancy experience:
-
Supportive Relationships: Women can connect with each other, offering mutual support during a significant time in their lives.
-
Empowerment: They become actively involved in their care, feeling more in control of their health and pregnancy journey.
-
Meaningful Services: The group model allows for more thorough Health Assessments and engaging discussions on important health topics.
These features work together to create a positive cycle: as women receive better care, they become more knowledgeable, confident, and engaged, leading to improved health outcomes.
The Malawi Group ANC Model
In Malawi, healthcare providers have taken the principles of Group ANC and made them work in the local context. They added two important health promotion topics: HIV prevention and Mental Health awareness. In a country grappling with high rates of HIV and mental health issues, this focus is essential.
Community volunteers, who are already well-established in public health efforts, were incorporated as co-facilitators in the Group ANC sessions. This modification helps integrate Community Support into the healthcare framework, making it more effective.
The Study
A trial was conducted in Malawi to assess whether Group ANC could improve outcomes for pregnant women compared to traditional Individual ANC. The results were collected from a large number of participants over several years. The findings were compared between those who attended Group ANC and those who went through Individual ANC.
Setting and Participants
Malawi has a free national healthcare system and has committed to providing universal health coverage. However, it struggles with limited funding and a shortage of healthcare personnel. The study was conducted across various clinics in the Blantyre District, representing different social and economic backgrounds.
How the Study Worked
Pregnant women arriving for their first ANC visit underwent an initial assessment to determine their eligibility. After consent, they completed a baseline survey. They were then randomly assigned to either Group ANC or Individual ANC, ensuring a fair comparison of outcomes.
Both groups had similar health assessments, but those in Group ANC enjoyed interactive sessions with their peers, while the Individual ANC group received standard care through shorter, traditional appointments.
Results of the Study
The study revealed that women who participated in Group ANC experienced significantly shorter wait times for services, higher satisfaction ratings, and a greater number of ANC visits. A surprising 95% of women who attended Group ANC expressed a desire to continue in that format for future pregnancies. It seems that the group setting might just be the cherry on top of prenatal care!
Knowledge and Behavior Improvements
Women in Group ANC scored better in terms of knowledge about healthy pregnancy practices compared to those in Individual ANC. They also reported better dietary habits, increased birth preparedness, and a greater likelihood of using condoms consistently for HIV prevention. Educational discussions during the Group ANC sessions likely played a vital role in these positive shifts in behavior.
Communication and Care Beyond ANC
The benefits of Group ANC also extended to partner communication. Women who participated reported better communication with their partners about pregnancy-related matters. However, there was no noticeable difference in uptake of postnatal care or family planning services between the two groups.
Clinical Outcomes
While Group ANC showed impressive improvements in many areas, not all clinical outcomes were significantly different. Low birth weight and other clinical measures did not show a marked difference between the two groups. This may be due to various factors, including how gestational age was assessed.
One surprising positive finding was that Group ANC participants reported lower mental distress, indicating that this approach could help improve mental health during pregnancy.
Limitations and External Challenges
Despite the promising results, a few limitations in the study should be acknowledged. For instance, challenges with accurately determining gestational age made it difficult to measure certain clinical outcomes. Additionally, the study faced external hurdles such as natural disasters and healthcare disruptions.
The Future of Group ANC
The success of Group ANC in Malawi has sparked interest in expanding this model to other low- and middle-income countries. With increasing evidence supporting its effectiveness, more countries are looking to adopt this innovative approach to maternal health care.
The Malawi Ministry of Health is already taking steps to introduce Group ANC in district-level trainings, which could lay the groundwork for nationwide adoption. With the right support, Group ANC could change the way we provide prenatal care, ensuring that more women receive the quality support they need to have healthy pregnancies.
Conclusion
Antenatal care is a crucial component of maternal health, and Group ANC offers a refreshing twist on traditional models. By fostering supportive relationships, empowering women, and providing meaningful services, this approach can enhance the pregnancy experience. The implementation of Group ANC in Malawi showcases its potential to improve outcomes in low-resource settings while addressing the unique health needs of women.
So, if you’re ever in Malawi and expecting a little bundle of joy, consider joining a Group ANC session—because who wouldn’t want to swap pregnancy tips while enjoying a supportive community?
Original Source
Title: Group antenatal care positively transforms the care experience: Results of an effectiveness trial in Malawi
Abstract: BackgroundWe developed and tested a Centering-based group antenatal (ANC) model in Malawi, integrating health promotion for HIV prevention and mental health. We present effectiveness data and examine congruence with the only Group ANC theory of change model, which identifies key processes as supportive relationships, empowered partners in learning and care, and meaningful services, leading to better ANC experiences and outcomes. MethodsWe conducted a hybrid effectiveness-implementation trial at seven clinics in Blantyre District, Malawi, comparing outcomes for 1887 pregnant women randomly assigned to Group ANC or Individual ANC. Group effects on outcomes were summarized and evaluated using t-tests, Mann-Whitney, or Chi-squared tests, and multivariable linear or logistic regression models adjusted for baseline outcomes, seven individual and two clinic-level covariates. All statistical tests were two-sided, controlling for a Type I error probability of 0.01 due to multiple testing. FindingsWomen in Group ANC had higher peer connectedness and pregnancy-related empowerment, recalled receiving more services, and discussed more health promotion topics. They experienced less wait time, greater satisfaction with care (Estimate = 1.21, 99% CI = 0.07, 2.35), had a higher mean number of ANC contacts (Estimate = 0.74, 99% CI = 0.50, 0.98), and were more likely to complete at least four or eight contacts. Most women preferred Group ANC for a future pregnancy (81% in Individual ANC; 95% in Group ANC). Women in Group ANC had more diverse diets (Estimate = 0.35, 99% CI = 0.17, 0.53), were better prepared for birth (Estimate 0.32, 99% CI = 0.16, 0.48), more likely to use condoms consistently (OR= 1.07, 99% CI = 1.00, 1.14) and communicated more with partners. They reported less mental distress in late pregnancy (Estimate = -0.61, 99% CI = -1.20, -0.02). Exclusive breastfeeding, partner HIV testing and disclosure, facility-based delivery, postnatal care attendance, postpartum family planning, and low birth weight did not differ by ANC type. ConclusionsThis effectiveness study of Malawi Group ANC, the first trial with individual randomization in a low-income country, maps outcomes to the theory of change, enhancing our understanding of Group ANCs diverse positive impacts. The integration of typically neglected health promotion topics highlights group cares flexibility to address local and global needs. Based on study results, the Malawi Ministry of Health is introducing Group ANC at district-level trainings and exploring the logistics for nationwide adoption. With momentum and political will, we are poised to bring better care and a positive healthcare experience to women, infants, and families throughout Malawi and globally.
Authors: Crystal L. Patil, Kathleen F. Norr, Esnath Kapito, Li C. Liu, Xiaohan Mei, Elizabeth T. Abrams, Elizabeth Chodzaza, Genesis Chorwe-Sungani, Ursula Kafulafula, Allissa Desloge, Ashley Gresh, Rohan D. Jeremiah, Dhruvi R. Patel, Anne Batchelder, Heidy Wang, Jocelyn Faydenko, Sharon S. Rising, Ellen Chirwa
Last Update: 2024-12-27 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.25.24319635
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.25.24319635.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.