Simple Science

Cutting edge science explained simply

# Physics# Earth and Planetary Astrophysics

The Role of Pebble Supply in Planetesimal Growth

This article examines how pebble availability influences the formation of planets.

― 7 min read


Pebbles and PlanetesimalPebbles and PlanetesimalGrowthplanetesimal mass growth.Investigating how pebble supply limits
Table of Contents

In the early stages of forming a planet, tiny Dust particles in a disk around a young star come together to form larger chunks called Planetesimals. These planetesimals can grow into planets over time. A vital part of this process involves small particles, known as Pebbles, which can greatly help in building up the mass of these planetesimals. The aim of this article is to discuss how the supply of pebbles affects the growth of planetesimals in protoplanetary disks.

The Core Accretion Model

The core accretion model explains how planets form from dust and gas in protoplanetary disks. In this model, tiny dust particles stick together to form pebbles. These pebbles collide and combine to create larger bodies, ultimately leading to planetesimals, which are massive enough to become the building blocks of planets. To create larger planets, planetesimals absorb gas from the disk surrounding them.

The growth of dust to the size of pebbles is often observed in young disks. However, for pebbles to turn into planetesimals, they need to have enough mass and inertia. Otherwise, they drift towards the central star in the disk and are lost.

Understanding Planetesimal Growth

The process of how planetesimals grow is not completely understood, but certain factors play a crucial role. A phenomenon called streaming instability can lead to dust clumping together, which might then collapse to form planetesimals. High concentrations of dust are needed for this to happen, yet such high concentrations are rarely found in protoplanetary disks.

Alternatively, there is a slow instability that occurs when dust particles stick together, increasing the dust-to-gas ratio, which can also initiate planetesimal formation.

Planetesimals can grow through two main methods: they can collide with each other or take in pebbles from the surrounding environment. The process of colliding and merging can lead to rapid growth when larger planetesimals grow faster than smaller ones.

The Role of Pebble Accretion

Pebble accretion is a critical process in planetesimal growth. It is where planetesimals gather pebbles from the disk, increasing their mass. This method can outpace growth through collisions as the pebbles are quickly absorbed.

The efficiency of pebble accretion heavily relies on how many pebbles are available in the surrounding disk and their size. Usually, studies assume a steady supply of pebbles, but reality shows that this supply can change over time and across different areas of the disk.

The dust in the disk evolves due to various processes, including gas movement and turbulence. These processes can affect how dust is transported throughout the disk, which ultimately influences the availability of pebbles for planetesimals to accrete.

Investigating Pebble Supply

In our study, we examine how variations in pebble supply affect the growth of planetesimals. This is done by creating simulations that model the movements and interactions of planetesimals with the pebbles in a changing environment.

The supply of pebbles can fluctuate due to factors like dust diffusion and gas pressure. We also find that the efficiency of growth is closely tied to the amount and distribution of pebbles over time.

Methodology and Simulations

To better understand planetesimal growth in evolving disks, we utilize a specific simulation model. This model allows us to track how planetesimals evolve as they interact with pebbles in a disk that changes over time.

Planetesimals tend to form around certain areas of the disk, called snow lines, where conditions may be favorable for growth. As the disk evolves, we simulate the interactions between planetesimals and the pebbles available to them.

The general approach applies different scenarios to observe how changes in the dust environment impact planetesimal growth.

Dust Evolution and Pebble Flux

The evolution of dust plays a significant role in shaping the supply of pebbles. As the dust changes over time, so does the concentration of pebbles. We see that in the early stages, areas with higher concentrations of dust can lead to greater pebble supplies.

However, this supply tends to decrease over time. Initial dust density peaks quickly disappear as dust is lost to the central star. This reduction in dust density influences the amount of pebbles available for planetesimals to collect.

The pebble flux is a crucial measure that reflects the rate at which pebbles are available in the disk. Our findings indicate that this pebble flux is not constant and tends to drop significantly after the early stages of disk evolution.

The Impact of Pebble Supply on Mass Growth

Pebble accretion is expected to enhance the growth of planetesimals significantly. Previous studies that assumed a constant supply of pebbles suggested that planetesimals could grow larger than Earth within a few million years. However, according to our simulation, the mass of planetesimals is generally much smaller than this.

Over the course of our study, we see that the mass of planetesimals tends to be limited. As time progresses, the available pebble supply diminishes, causing a drop in the rates at which planetesimals can grow. Most planetesimals in our simulations struggled to exceed certain mass thresholds after 2 million years.

Observations of Different Simulation Scenarios

Our simulations feature various models that investigate factors such as dust concentration and gas viscosity. Each of these elements plays a role in shaping how effectively planetesimals can accrete pebbles over time.

In different scenarios, we observe how altering dust concentrations can impact planetesimal mass growth significantly. For instance, when there is a higher initial concentration of dust, planetesimals tend to grow more rapidly.

Moreover, the effects of viscosity also play a role in determining how quickly dust moves and how readily pebbles are available for planetesimals to absorb. Lower viscosity can lead to a more favorable environment for pebble accretion.

Dynamics of Dust and Pebble Supply

As dust moves and evolves, it affects the overall dynamics within the protoplanetary disk. The way in which dust is distributed and concentrated can impact how pebbles are transported and ultimately influence the growth of planetesimals.

Dust can either be pushed outward or drawn inward by the surrounding gas. Dust diffusion adds another layer of complexity, leading to uneven distributions of pebbles throughout the disk.

As we run our simulations, we can closely observe how these factors interplay and create a dynamic environment that shapes the available supply of pebbles.

Challenges in Growth Due to Limited Pebble Supply

One of the most striking findings from our research is the limitations imposed by pebble supply on the growth of planetesimals. As time passes, the initial abundance of pebbles dwindles, and this decline hampers the ability of planetesimals to grow significantly.

The slow decrease in pebble supply means that even planetesimals that start with sufficient mass may not be able to grow beyond specific limits. This suggests that many planetesimals may remain small and not transition into larger planetary bodies within the lifetime of the disk.

Future Studies and Considerations

Given our findings, it is evident that further studies are necessary to explore how varying conditions affect pebble supply and planetesimal growth. This includes examining multiple dust types and conditions across various disk environments.

Understanding the complete dynamics of pebbles and dust in protoplanetary disks could lead to better insights into planet formation. Ongoing research will focus on how to create simulations that account for these complexities.

Conclusion

Our investigation into the growth of planetesimals within evolving protoplanetary disks highlights the crucial role of pebble supply. The results demonstrate that as the disk evolves, the amount and availability of pebbles change, significantly influencing the mass growth of planetesimals.

The study emphasizes that most planetesimals struggle to grow to substantial masses due to a declining pebble supply. Understanding these dynamics offers valuable insights into the processes involved in planet formation and encourages further exploration into the complexities of protoplanetary disks.

Original Source

Title: Planetesimal Growth in Evolving Protoplanetary Disks: Constraints from the Pebble Supply

Abstract: In the core accretion model, planetesimals grow by mutual collisions and engulfing millimeter-to-centimeter particles, i.e., pebbles. Pebble accretion can significantly increase the accretion efficiency and help explain the presence of planets on wide orbits. However, the pebble supply is typically parameterized as a coherent pebble mass flux, sometimes being constant in space and time. Here we solve the dust advection and diffusion within viciously evolving protoplanetary disks to determine the pebble supply self-consistently. The pebbles are then accreted by planetesimals interacting with the gas disk via gas drag and gravitational torque. The pebble supply is variable with space and decays with time quickly, with a pebble flux below 10 $M_\oplus$ Myr$^{-1}$ after 1 Myr in our models. As a result, only when massive planetesimals ($>$ 0.01 $M_\oplus$) are luckily produced by the streaming instability or the disk has low viscosity ($\alpha \sim 0.0001$) can the herd of planetesimals grow over a Mars mass within 2 Myr. By then, planetesimals only capture pebbles about 50 times their mass and as little as 10 times beyond 20 au due to limited pebble supply. Further studies considering multiple dust species in various disk conditions are warranted to fully assess the realistic pebble supply and its influence on planetesimal growth.

Authors: Tong Fang, Hui Zhang, Shangfei Liu, Beibei Liu, Hongping Deng

Last Update: 2023-04-15 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.03621

Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.03621

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

More from authors

Similar Articles