Cognitive Impact of Anticholinergic Medications in Bipolar Disorder
Study reveals cognitive risks from anticholinergic drugs in bipolar patients.
― 5 min read
Table of Contents
Bipolar Disorders (BD) are mood disorders that affect a small portion of the population. They are divided into two main types: Type I and Type II. Individuals with these disorders can experience episodes of mania (high energy) and depression (low energy). These conditions can influence cognitive abilities across all stages of the illness.
Cognitive Impairments are seen not only during manic and depressive episodes but can also persist when the person feels stable, known as the euthymic phase. Tests show that up to 39.7% of individuals with BD may have some form of cognitive impairment during the euthymic state. These cognitive issues can lead to more mood episodes, a lower quality of life, and difficulties in social interactions.
Current Treatment Methods
The treatment for bipolar disorder mainly involves medication. Over the years, the use of certain drugs known for their anticholinergic properties has increased. Anticholinergic drugs affect a chemical in the brain called acetylcholine and are often used to treat various mental health issues. However, their impact on cognitive functions in individuals with BD has not been fully studied.
Most psychotropic drugs can help with mood episodes, leading to better cognitive performance during those times. Yet, some Medications can leave lingering cognitive problems when the person is stable. This raises concerns about the anticholinergic effects of these medications, as they can impair cognition in otherwise healthy people.
To address this, researchers have developed scales to evaluate the Anticholinergic Burden of medications. These scales help determine how much these drugs might affect cognitive function. While they've been studied in other populations, their application in bipolar disorders has only been explored in a limited way.
Study Description
A recent study aimed to evaluate different anticholinergic burden scales to see how they relate to cognitive impairment and reported Side Effects in individuals with bipolar disorder. Patients were recruited from various centers in France, and the study ensured ethical guidelines were followed.
To participate, individuals had to be between 18 and 65 years old and diagnosed with bipolar disorder. They needed to be in a stable condition, experiencing no mood symptoms at the time of testing. People with other cognitive disorders or substance abuse issues were excluded to prevent other factors from influencing cognitive performance.
Assessing Anticholinergic Burden
Researchers identified 36 scales that could measure the anticholinergic burden of medications. They then excluded seven scales based on specific criteria. For those medicines not included in any scale, the researchers assumed they had no anticholinergic properties.
To determine the total anticholinergic burden, they used two methods: summing the scores of all treatments or taking the highest score of any single treatment. Neuropsychologists tested participants using a standardized battery of cognitive tests to assess different domains such as processing speed, memory, attention, working memory, executive function, and reasoning.
Side effects from medications were assessed through a detailed inventory that included common issues like dry mouth and constipation. This helped researchers understand the connection between cognitive impairment and self-reported medication side effects.
Collecting Data
The study included over 2,000 participants diagnosed with bipolar disorder, with a majority being female. A notable portion was identified as cognitively impaired, indicating significant cognitive challenges within this population.
Researchers found discrepancies in how different scales reported anticholinergic properties. This revealed a need for clearer tools to assess these burdens in bipolar disorder patients.
Cognitive Impairment and Anticholinergic Scales
Bivariable analyses showed that many of the anticholinergic scales were positively linked to cognitive impairment when examining their scores. Among those, two scales stood out: Chew’s scale and the Anticholinergic Toxicity Scale. An increase in scores on these scales suggested a higher risk of cognitive impairment.
Interestingly, other commonly prescribed medications like lithium and certain antipsychotics were also linked to cognitive issues. However, the direction of this relationship remains unclear, as cognitive impairment could lead to more aggressive treatment rather than being simply a side effect of the medication.
Individual Cognitive Domains
When looking closely at specific cognitive functions, the Chew scale and the Anticholinergic Toxicity Scale were associated with poorer performance in areas like processing speed and verbal memory. This indicates that these cognitive functions may be particularly sensitive to the anticholinergic burden.
Side Effects and Anticholinergic Scales
The research also assessed how various scales related to reported side effects. Many scales were linked to common peripheral side effects such as dry mouth and central side effects like sleepiness. This helps highlight the broader implications of anticholinergic medications beyond just their impact on cognition.
The results showed that multiple scales correlated with an increase in self-reported side effects, suggesting that these scales might not only measure anticholinergic burden accurately but also capture other medication-related issues.
Implications of the Study
This study demonstrates the need to monitor the cognitive effects of medications used in treating bipolar disorder. The findings suggest that two scales can effectively identify patients who may be at risk for cognitive impairment due to their medication.
Moreover, the study highlights the importance of understanding not just the cognitive effects but also the range of side effects that may arise from these drugs. Reducing medication load and carefully considering treatment options could improve cognitive tolerability and overall patient well-being.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the study provides valuable insights, it is limited by its cross-sectional design, meaning it captures a snapshot rather than looking at changes over time. This consideration is important as it muddles the ability to make causal conclusions about the relationship between medication use and cognitive impairment.
Future research should involve longitudinal studies to assess the ongoing effects of medications on cognition, accounting for the dosage and duration of treatment. This would provide a clearer picture of how various treatments impact cognitive functioning in bipolar disorder over time.
In summary, understanding the cognitive effects of anticholinergic medications in individuals with bipolar disorder is crucial. The scales developed to measure anticholinergic burden can serve as tools for clinicians to gauge potential cognitive risks associated with treatment and improve patient care.
Title: Comparative analysis of anticholinergic burden scales to explain iatrogenic cognitive impairment and self-reported side effects in the euthymic phase of bipolar disorders: results from the FACE-BD cohort
Abstract: Bipolar disorders (BD) are characterized by cognitive impairment during the euthymic phase, to which treatments can contribute. The anticholinergic properties of medications, i.e., the ability of a treatment to inhibit cholinergic receptors, are associated with cognitive impairment in elderly patients and people with schizophrenia but this association has not been well characterized in individuals with remitted bipolar disorders. Moreover, the validity of anticholinergic burden scales designed to assess the anticholinergic load of medications has been scarcely tested in bipolar disorders. We aimed to test the concurrent validity of several scales by assessing their associations with objective cognitive impairment and subjective anticholinergic side-effects in BD. We hypothesized that the scale is valid if its association with cognitive impairment or self-reported anticholinergic side-effects is significant. A sample of 2,031 individuals with euthymic bipolar disorders was evaluated with a neuropsychological battery to identify cognitive impairment. Two scales among 27 were significantly positively associated with cognitive impairment in multiple logistic regressions, whereas chlorpromazine equivalents, lorazepam equivalents, the number of antipsychotics, or the number of treatments were not. The two scales significantly correlated with worse performance in processing speed and verbal memory. In addition, 14 scales showed good concurrent validity to assess self-reported peripheral anticholinergic side-effects and 13 were valid for evaluating self-reported central anticholinergic side-effects. Thus, we identified valid scales to monitor the anticholinergic burden in BD, which may be useful in assessing iatrogenic cognitive impairment in studies investigating cognition in BD.
Authors: Nathan Vidal, E. Brunet-Gouet, S. Frileux, B. Aouizerate, V. Aubin, R. Belzeaux, P. Courtet, T. D'Amato, C. Dubertret, B. Etain, E. Haffen, D. Januel, M. Leboyer, A. Lefrere, P.-M. Llorca, E. Marlinge, E. Olie, M. Polosan, R. Schwan, M. Walter, the FACE-BD (FondaMental Academic Centers of Expertise for Bipolar Disorders) group, C. Passerieux, P. Roux
Last Update: 2023-04-17 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.10.23288347
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.10.23288347.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.