Challenges and Opportunities in Web3 and Blockchain Technologies
Exploring the potential and obstacles facing Web3 and blockchain advancements.
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
People have high hopes for Web3 and Blockchain technologies, believing they can change how we live and work. Supporters argue that these technologies can give more control to individuals and share power among a larger group of people. However, developers face real-life challenges that can slow down progress. This article looks at the visions of those involved in Web3 and blockchain technologies and highlights the obstacles they face that could put their goals at risk.
Background on Blockchain and Web3
Blockchain is a special kind of technology that allows people to make secure transactions without needing a bank or another middleman. Bitcoin, created in 2008, is one of the first examples and demonstrates how these technologies can work. The idea is that people should have control over their financial transactions instead of relying on banks, which can be seen as corrupt or self-serving.
Beyond Bitcoin, blockchain has led to various applications, like unique digital items known as non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and new ways of organizing finance, called decentralized finance (DeFi). These technologies aim to create a new version of the internet-often called Web3-that empowers users and reduces the influence of large tech companies.
Decentralization
The Role ofDecentralization is a key idea in Web3. It suggests that power and control should be spread out rather than concentrated in a few hands. In traditional systems, such as banks or large social media platforms, a select group makes decisions for everyone else. In contrast, Web3 seeks to let users decide collectively how technology should work.
Decentralized systems allow users to control their data and financial resources directly, avoiding the pitfalls associated with centralized entities. However, achieving true decentralization is complicated. Many things can influence whether a system remains decentralized, including the way it is built and external factors like natural disasters or economic pressures.
Challenges Facing Web3 and Blockchain
Despite the goals of empowering users, various challenges can arise:
Governance
1. Balancing Speed andFor new blockchain projects, moving quickly to meet user needs is crucial. However, to genuinely implement decentralized governance, projects often struggle to find the right balance. Early-stage projects may keep a core team in place to make quick decisions, which can reduce true decentralization. This dual structure can cause tension as the teams try to eventually shift to more community-driven governance.
2. Broadening Reach to Mainstream Users
As Web3 technologies become more popular, they attract a wider range of users, including those motivated by profit rather than the original ideals of decentralization. This shift could distort the technology's intended purpose, as some new users might seek quick gains instead of genuine participation in a decentralized community.
3. Conflicts of Interest with Investors
Many blockchain projects rely on venture capital for funding, which makes them vulnerable to pressures from investors. These investors often prioritize their own financial returns over the project's ideals. This can lead to a mismatch between the intentions of the developers and the expectations of those financing their work.
Scams and Fraud
4. AddressingThe blockchain space has attracted both genuine enthusiasts and scammers. Many users have fallen victim to scams, Ponzi schemes, or unsustainable projects. This issue tarnishes the technology's reputation and can discourage potential new users from participating.
Promises of Web3
Supporters of Web3 identify several major benefits:
1. User Control and Ownership
One of the key promises of decentralized technologies is that they give users control over their own data and assets. Many feel that large tech companies have too much power over personal data, and decentralized systems can help restore ownership to the users themselves.
2. Fair Governance
Decentralized governance provides an opportunity for all users to participate in decision-making. Instead of being dictated by a few executives, users have a voice in shaping how platforms operate, promoting what they see as a fairer approach.
Financial Inclusion
3.Web3 is also seen as a way to improve access to financial tools for everyone, especially those who may not have benefited from traditional banking services. Technologies like DeFi aim to enable individuals from all backgrounds to access financial resources without the restrictions imposed by banks or governments.
Potential Harms of Web3
While there are many promises, there are also pitfalls:
1. Risk of Corruption
If decentralized systems aren't managed properly, they can still fall victim to corruption or mismanagement. A well-known example is Celsius Network, which faced significant issues due to unaccountable leadership. Even with a transparent blockchain, if individuals within the system misuse their influence, it can lead to disastrous outcomes.
2. Financial Inequality
Despite the promise of equal access, many blockchain technologies can unintentionally create or perpetuate economic disparity. Users who get in early on popular projects often benefit the most, while newcomers may only act as exit liquidity for those with greater resources.
3. Prevalence of Scams
Scams are rampant in the blockchain space, causing individuals to lose significant amounts of money. The challenges of identifying legitimate projects mean that even experienced users can fall victim. This creates an environment of distrust that could hinder user participation.
Exploring Solutions
To address current problems in Web3, several potential solutions have emerged:
1. User Education
One widely suggested approach is that users take responsibility for educating themselves about the technologies they engage with. The phrase "Do Your Own Research" (DYOR) has become popular in blockchain communities, encouraging individuals to thoroughly investigate before investing.
2. Regulation
While some view government oversight as a threat, others see it as an opportunity to create clear rules that protect users from scams and provide guidelines for responsible project development. However, finding a balance between regulation and the original ideals of Web3 can be difficult.
3. Commitment to Core Principles
Some participants in the blockchain space advocate for a stronger commitment to the original ideals behind the technology, such as decentralization and transparency. By holding fast to these principles, there may be less risk of the technology being misused or corrupted.
Conclusion
The vision for Web3 and blockchain technologies is one where users have more control, financial inclusion is improved, and governance is more participatory. Yet, achieving these goals is a work in progress. Developers face significant obstacles, including balancing efficiency with decentralization, attracting mainstream users, managing investor interests, and combating fraud.
While there are many promising aspects to these technologies, they are not without their challenges. The path forward will require careful navigation of these tensions, emphasizing education, encouraging regulation, and recommitting to the foundational ideals that inspired their creation. Only then can we hope to realize the full potential of what Web3 and blockchain can offer.
Title: Techno-Utopians, Scammers, and Bullshitters: The Promise and Peril of Web3 and Blockchain Technologies According to Operators and Venture Capital Investors
Abstract: Proponents and developers of Web3 and blockchain argue that these technologies can revolutionize how people live and work by empowering individuals and distributing decision-making power. While technologists often have expansive hopes for what their technologies will accomplish over the long term, the practical challenges of developing, scaling, and maintaining systems amidst present-day constraints can compromise progress toward this vision. How technologists think about the technological future they hope to enable and how they navigate day-to-day issues impacts the form technologies take, their potential benefits, and their potential harms. In our current work, we aimed to explore the visions of Web3 and blockchain technologists and identify the immediate challenges that could threaten their visions. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 29 operators and professional investors in the Web3 and blockchain field. Our findings revealed that participants supported several ideological goals for their projects, with decentralization being a pivotal mechanism to enable user autonomy, distribute governance power, and promote financial inclusion. However, participants acknowledged the practical difficulties in fulfilling these promises, including the need for rapid technology development, conflicts of interest among stakeholders due to platform financing dynamics, and the challenge of expanding to mainstream users who may not share the "Web3 ethos." If negotiated ineffectively, these challenges could lead to negative outcomes, such as corrupt governance, increased inequality, and increased prevalence of scams and dubious investment schemes. While participants thought education, regulation, and a renewed commitment to the original blockchain ideals could alleviate some problems, they expressed skepticism about the potential of these solutions.
Authors: Amy A. Winecoff, Johannes Lenhard
Last Update: 2023-11-07 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10222
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10222
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.
Reference Links
- https://dl.acm.org/ccs.cfm
- https://drive.google.com/file/d/1oOUJrOE0Kd3arBPZj2ItF5rKFOJLC4NC/view?usp=sharing
- https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep328293/
- https://blockgeeks.com
- https://capitalizemytitle.com/
- https://www.acm.org/publications/proceedings-template
- https://www.acm.org/publications/class-2012
- https://dl.acm.org/ccs/ccs.cfm
- https://ctan.org/pkg/booktabs
- https://goo.gl/VLCRBB
- https://www.acm.org/publications/taps/describing-figures/
- https://www.coindesk.com/learn/the-fall-of-terra-a-timeline-of-the-meteoric-rise-and-crash-of-ust-and-luna/
- https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2022/07/15/the-fall-of-celsius-network-a-timeline-of-the-crypto-lenders-descent-into-insolvency/
- https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/11/11/ftx-files-for-bankruptcy-protections-in-us/
- https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/18zpVsnsC-l7nqJKG1PyOGdh4OBYDSjS4yvz720t-cT0/edit?usp=sharing