Enhancing Galaxy Catalogs Through Improved Deblending Techniques
A new method for better understanding galaxy evolution by refining far-infrared data.
― 9 min read
Table of Contents
- Methodology
- The Importance of Deblending
- Data Sources
- Initial Prior Catalog Construction
- Deblending Process
- Results from Simulations
- Application to Real Observations
- Performance Metrics
- Importance of Cross-Matching
- Scientific Applications
- Star Formation Main Sequence
- Far-Infrared to Radio Correlation
- Future Directions
- Conclusion
- Original Source
- Reference Links
Studying galaxies and their evolution is crucial for understanding the universe. One major challenge in this field is that a lot of the light from Star Formation and active supermassive black holes is hidden by dust. This dust absorbs light in the ultraviolet and optical range and re-emits it at longer wavelengths, particularly in the far-infrared and sub-millimeter ranges. Observations in these wavelengths are essential for getting a clear picture of cosmic star formation history.
The problem arises when trying to match galaxies detected at different wavelengths. The resolution varies greatly between these observations, making it difficult to identify the same galaxy in different datasets. This work aims to address that by creating improved Catalogs of galaxies detected in far-infrared and sub-millimeter light.
Methodology
To improve the existing catalogs, we have developed a method that extracts data from lower-resolution images at the locations of known galaxies. This approach focuses on deep extragalactic survey fields, and we present an application of this method in the COSMOS field.
Our method involves a Deblending process that utilizes a statistical framework called MCMC (Markov Chain Monte Carlo) combined with a Bayesian approach, known as XID+. The process begins with the most well-established data from the Spitzer satellite at 24 micrometers. We start by creating a list of prior sources based on previous catalogs and modeling their expected Fluxes. This helps us estimate and predict the strength of signals we might detect even in lower-resolution images.
Once we have deblended the data at 24 micrometers, we extend the process to include data from the Herschel satellite across various wavelengths, ranging from 100 to 500 micrometers. Each step builds on the results of the previous step by updating our prior list based on the new information we gather.
We validated our methodology using simulated data to ensure that the outputs would be reliable when applied to real observations. The results demonstrated that our deblending process significantly improves the accuracy of flux measurements.
The Importance of Deblending
In deep observations, many sources can appear blended together in the same image, complicating the task of identifying individual galaxies. This blending can mask the true properties of these galaxies, leading to misinterpretations of their behavior and characteristics.
Deblending is essential because it allows us to separate the contributions of different sources, giving us a clearer picture of each one. By refining how we detect and measure the light emitted by these galaxies, we can gain insights into star formation and Galaxy Evolution that might otherwise remain hidden.
Data Sources
To construct our initial catalog, we focused on two critical datasets: the COSMOS2020 catalog, which provides a comprehensive set of multi-wavelength data, and radio catalogs that help identify sources missing from the optical data.
The COSMOS2020 catalog is an updated version of earlier releases, providing improved measurements for roughly 1.7 million sources across various wavelengths. This wealth of information enables us to make more accurate predictions about the fluxes we expect to see in the far-infrared and sub-millimeter ranges.
Radio data is particularly useful because it can help identify high-redshift sources that may not be adequately detected in optical surveys. By combining both datasets, we enhance the reliability of the prior catalog that serves as the foundation for our deblending process.
Initial Prior Catalog Construction
To create the initial prior catalog, we first extracted relevant data from the COSMOS2020 catalog and combined it with the source information from our radio catalogs. We focused on sources that were likely to contribute to the far-infrared and sub-millimeter emissions.
The SED (spectral energy distribution) fitting process plays a significant role here. By applying sophisticated models, we can estimate how much light a source would emit at different wavelengths. This helps us select the most relevant sources to include in our prior catalog for deblending.
In addition to using traditional methods, we incorporated a deep learning model trained on the outputs of our SED fitting. This helps accelerate the flux prediction step, making the process more efficient.
Deblending Process
Once we had established our initial prior catalog, we could begin the deblending process using the far-infrared and sub-millimeter data. We adopted a progressive approach, starting with the 24 micrometer data and moving to longer wavelengths, which enhances the reliability of our results.
In each step, we used information from the previous deblending results to update our list of sources. This iterative process allowed us to refine our measurements continually, resulting in a more accurate final catalog.
As we proceeded from the 24 micrometer data to the Herschel PACS and SPIRE data, we maintained a close relationship with the prior sources, ensuring that we accounted for the visible correlations between different wavelengths.
Results from Simulations
To verify the effectiveness of our methodology, we compared the results from simulated data with the outputs generated through our deblending pipeline. This validation illustrated that we could achieve high levels of accuracy, even when dealing with faint sources.
For the 24 micrometer data, we found that our deblended flux measurements were consistent with expectations and provided reliable estimates down to the noise level. The same level of accuracy was achieved for the PACS data, where we were able to deblend sources down to roughly the confusion noise level.
The performance remained strong even as we transitioned to analyzing SPIRE data, which is often more challenging due to the presence of many overlapping sources. Our results showed that we could effectively separate these sources while retaining a high degree of accuracy in our measurements.
Application to Real Observations
After validating our methods through simulations, we applied them to real observational data, starting with the Spitzer 24 micrometer map. We compared our results against existing catalogs which contain a selection of bright sources.
The agreement between our deblended results and the previous catalogs was encouraging and demonstrated that our approach successfully captured the true properties of the sources while mitigating the effects of blending.
Next, we applied the same methodology to the Herschel PACS and SPIRE data, again comparing our results with blind and super-deblended catalogs. The findings indicated that our deblended catalog displayed high accuracy for far-infrared measurements, aligning well with previous studies, especially for brighter sources.
Performance Metrics
To evaluate the performance of our deblending method, we employed several metrics to quantify accuracy and precision. For the 24 micrometer data, we noted a median difference of just a few joules, which signifies a high level of accuracy against existing benchmarks.
In the PACS bands, our method also yielded a median unbiased result, indicating successful detection at relatively low flux levels. The accuracy of measurements improved as the brightness of the sources increased, although we noted a slight systematic underestimation for fainter sources.
For the SPIRE data, we observed similar trends, with the performance metrics suggesting that our method efficiently addressed the inherent challenges posed by confusion noise in these longer wavelengths.
Importance of Cross-Matching
One critical aspect of our work involved cross-matching sources from various catalogs. This process helps ensure that we can track the same galaxies across different observational datasets, facilitating a more comprehensive understanding of their properties.
Through careful matching, we could identify sources that might have been omitted from previous analyses. The enhanced ability to link far-infrared and sub-millimeter data with optical and radio observations allows astronomers to build a more cohesive picture of how galaxies evolve over time.
Scientific Applications
Our new deblended far-infrared and sub-millimeter photometry catalog opens up numerous opportunities for scientific exploration. Various investigations can utilize this data, including studies of star formation rates, galaxy development, and the impacts of dust on galaxy evolution.
We specifically highlight two application areas: the galaxy star formation main sequence and the correlation between far-infrared and radio emissions. These studies offer insights into the relationships between different types of galaxies and their growth.
Star Formation Main Sequence
The star formation main sequence (SFMS) describes the correlation between stellar mass and star formation rate across cosmic time. Using our new catalog, we can examine this relationship for various galaxies and assess how it evolves with redshift.
By generating estimates of stellar mass and star formation rates, we can position galaxies within this established framework. This not only helps in validating previous findings but also allows us to assess how our new measurements influence interpretations of the SFMS.
Far-Infrared to Radio Correlation
Another critical area of exploration is the far-infrared to radio correlation, which describes the relationship between emissions from these two wavelengths in star-forming galaxies. Understanding this correlation can provide insights into the underlying physics of galaxy behavior and star formation processes.
By utilizing our deblended data, we can investigate how this correlation behaves across different redshifts and in various types of galaxies, enhancing our understanding of cosmic evolution.
Future Directions
While this work represents a significant advancement in the field, there are still many opportunities for further exploration. As new observational data becomes available from upcoming missions, we can apply our deblending methodology to even larger and deeper extragalactic survey fields.
The arrival of new telescopes and advanced observational techniques will greatly enhance our ability to gather high-quality data across multiple wavelengths. This additional information can be invaluable for refining our priors and improving deblending processes, leading to continuously better photometry catalogs.
Conclusion
Our new deblended point source catalog provides a robust foundation for future studies in galaxy evolution. By effectively separating sources and enhancing the accuracy of flux measurements at far-infrared and sub-millimeter wavelengths, we can shed light on previously obscured aspects of the universe.
Through rigorous validation and comparison with existing benchmarks, we are confident that our approach offers a reliable and scientifically sound method for extracting valuable astronomical information. Future applications of this catalog will undoubtedly contribute to our understanding of the cosmos and the evolution of galaxies within it.
Title: Probabilistic and progressive deblended far-infrared and sub-millimetre point source catalogues I. Methodology and first application in the COSMOS field
Abstract: Single-dish far-infrared (far-IR) and sub-millimetre (sub-mm) point source catalogues and their connections with catalogues at other wavelengths are of paramount importance. However, due to the large mismatch in spatial resolution, cross-matching galaxies at different wavelengths is challenging. This work aims to develop the next-generation deblended far-IR and sub-mm catalogues and present the first application in the COSMOS field. Our progressive deblending used the Bayesian probabilistic framework known as XID+. The deblending started from the Spitzer/MIPS 24 micron data, using an initial prior list composed of sources selected from the COSMOS2020 catalogue and radio catalogues from the VLA and the MeerKAT surveys, based on spectral energy distribution modelling which predicts fluxes of the known sources at the deblending wavelength. To speed up flux prediction, we made use of a neural network-based emulator. After deblending the 24 micron data, we proceeded to the Herschel PACS (100 & 160 micron) and SPIRE wavebands (250, 350 & 500 micron). Each time we constructed a tailor-made prior list based on the predicted fluxes of the known sources. Using simulated far-IR and sub-mm sky, we detailed the performance of our deblending pipeline. After validation with simulations, we then deblended the real observations from 24 to 500 micron and compared with blindly extracted catalogues and previous versions of deblended catalogues. As an additional test, we deblended the SCUBA-2 850 micron map and compared our deblended fluxes with ALMA measurements, which demonstrates a higher level of flux accuracy compared to previous results.We publicly release our XID+ deblended point source catalogues. These deblended long-wavelength data are crucial for studies such as deriving the fraction of dust-obscured star formation and better separation of quiescent galaxies from dusty star-forming galaxies.
Authors: Lingyu Wang, Antonio La Marca, Fangyou Gao, William J. Pearson, Berta Margalef-Bentabol, Matthieu Béthermin, Longji Bing, James Donnellan, Peter D. Hurley, Seb J. Oliver, Catherine L. Hale, Matt J. Jarvis, Lucia Marchetti, Mattia Vaccari, Imogen H. Whittam
Last Update: 2024-05-28 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18290
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18290
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.
Reference Links
- https://cosmos2020.calet.org/catalogues/
- https://cosmos2020.calet.org/catalogues/MASKS/MASKS_README.txt
- https://irsa.ipac.caltech.edu/data/COSMOS/images/spitzer/mips/
- https://www.mpe.mpg.de/ir/Research/PEP/DR1
- https://www.mpe.mpg.de/resources/PEP/DR1_tarballs/readme_PEP_global.pdf
- https://hedam.lam.fr/HerMES/
- https://github.com/H-E-L-P/XID_plus
- https://hedam.lam.fr/HELP/dataproducts/dmu26/dmu26_XID+COSMOS2024/