Simple Science

Cutting edge science explained simply

# Physics # Astrophysics of Galaxies

The Mystery of Supermassive Black Holes

New insights challenge our understanding of black hole growth in the universe.

Knud Jahnke

― 5 min read


Secrets of Black Hole Secrets of Black Hole Growth theories of cosmic giants. Hidden black holes challenge existing
Table of Contents

Supermassive Black Holes (SMBHs) are the cosmic giants hiding at the centers of most galaxies. They grow by gobbling up gas, stars, and anything else that comes too close. But here’s the twist: just how these black holes grow in the early universe is a bit of a head-scratcher.

Meet the Quasars

Quasars are bright objects powered by supermassive black holes. They shine brightly because they are consuming material at a rapid pace. Imagine a cosmic vacuum cleaner that not only sucks up everything around it but also lights up like a disco ball while doing so. Most of the cheerful quasars we see are relatively unobscured, meaning we can easily spot them through our telescopes.

A Surprising Discovery

Recent research has thrown a wrench into the notion that these shimmering quasars are the main contributors to how supermassive black holes grew in the early universe. It turns out, they may only account for a tiny fraction of the total mass growth. So, if quasars are the party lights, it seems like the real party is happening behind closed doors, away from the flashy lights.

The 'Sołtan Argument'

The Sołtan argument is a fancy way of comparing how much mass we think quasars are building by eating versus how much mass is actually present in supermassive black holes out there. It’s like trying to link how many slices of pizza you ate last night to the number of pizza boxes in your kitchen – the two might not match up!

In a nutshell, if we take the mass contributions from these flashy quasars into account, we find they contribute less than 10% of what we measure from the total mass density of supermassive black holes. Yep, that’s right! Most of the growth happens in obscured places, where Dust and gas hide these hungry black holes from our view.

The Missing Mass

So where is this missing mass coming from? Researchers believe that a large portion of black hole growth occurs in obscured regions where dust absorbs light. These hidden black holes are likely feasting away in a different manner – potentially at a rate faster than we can see. Picture a secret food festival where all the delicious treats are tucked away in dark corners.

The Role of Dust

Dust plays a significant role in this cosmic drama. It’s like having an invisibility cloak that keeps black holes from revealing their true size and growth. Researchers think that as much as 90% of the black hole growth may happen in these hidden, dusty systems. It’s as if the universe decided to throw a huge black-tie event – exciting and packed full of action, but all the interesting bits are happening behind closed doors!

Short Lived Quasars

Quasars that we can observe are estimated to have short lifespans in their bright stages. Recent findings suggest these luminous phases are unlikely to last long in the grand scheme of things. They’re like shooting stars – bright and brilliant but gone before you know it. This is consistent with studies that suggest most quasars are already towards the end of their growth phases when we finally observe them.

The Seed Problem

Here comes the kicker: the long-standing "seed problem" – the question of how black holes might start out from tiny seeds and grow into the supermassive beasts we see today. Traditionally, it was thought that these black holes must come from massive seeds that formed early in the universe. But as we’re discovering, this isn’t quite the full picture.

If their growth mainly occurs in these hidden, dusty environments, the need for massive black hole seeds, which have not been observed, might not actually be necessary. It’s like realizing you can make a grand meal without having to buy the most expensive ingredients. Who knew?

The Great Escape

There’s also a chance that many black holes may start their lives in conditions that are far from serene. They could grow rapidly in dense clouds of gas and dust. Think of it as a gathering of enthusiastic eaters at an all-you-can-eat buffet – they just can’t get enough and gobble everything up before anyone notices.

Searching for Evidence

Now, what does all this mean for our future observations? We might need to change how we search for these black holes. Instead of sticking strictly to visible wavelengths, we might want to look deeper into the infrared spectrum. Those secret black holes may be glowing quietly in the infrared, waiting for us to notice their existence!

The Little Red Dots

In the vastness of the cosmos, researchers have spotted a peculiar group of objects known as "Little Red Dots." These faint sources might be hiding a wealth of information about early black holes. If they indeed contain black holes, they may change our understanding of how these giants evolve.

Understanding the Growth Processes

Researchers have now opened the door to a myriad of questions regarding the growth processes of supermassive black holes. What happens when we finally uncover these hidden black holes? Will it change everything we thought we knew about black hole formation? The answer is likely yes, as new evidence continues to emerge.

The Future of Black Hole Research

The research surrounding supermassive black holes is just at the tip of the iceberg. There’s still so much we don’t know, and as technology improves and new telescopes come online, our view of the universe will expand.

So, keep your eyes on the stars, and don’t be surprised if we find that the universe has many more secrets to share as we continue to unveil the enigmatic world of supermassive black holes. Who knows what we will find next?

Original Source

Title: The Soltan argument at $z=6$: UV-luminous quasars contribute less than 10% to early black hole mass growth

Abstract: We combine stellar mass functions and the recent first JWST-based galaxy-black hole scaling relations at $z=6$ to for the first time compute the supermassive black hole (SMBH) mass volume density at this epoch, and compare this to the integrated SMBH mass growth from the population of UV-luminous quasars at $z>6$. We show that even under very conservative assumptions almost all growth of SMBH mass at $z>6$ does not take place in these UV-luminous quasars, but must occur in systems obscured through dust and/or with lower radiative efficiency than standard thin accretion disks. The `Soltan argument' is not fulfilled by the known population of bright quasars at $z>6$: the integrated SMBH mass growth inferred from these largely unobscured active galactic nuclei (AGN) in the early Universe is by a factor $\ge$10 smaller than the total SMBH mass volume density at $z=6$. This is valid under a large range of assumption about luminosity, mass functions, and accretion modes, and is likely still a factor >2 smaller when accounting for known obscuration fractions at this epoch. The resulting consequences are: >90%, possibly substantially more, of SMBH-buildup in the early Universe does not take place in luminous unobscured quasar phases, but has to occur in obscured systems, with dust absorbing most of the emitted UV-visible AGN emission, potentially with accretion modes with super-Eddington specific accretion rates. This is consistent with short lifetimes for luminous quasar phases from quasar proximity zone studies and clustering. This would remove the empirical need for slow SMBH growth and hence exotic `high-mass seed' black holes at early cosmic time. It also predicts a large population of luminous but very obscured lower-mass quasars at $z>6$, possibly the JWST `Little Red Dots'. This finding might severe impact on how we will diagnose SMBH growth at $z=7$ to 15 in the future.

Authors: Knud Jahnke

Last Update: 2024-11-05 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.03184

Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.03184

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

Similar Articles