How Viruses Spread in Elementary Schools
A study reveals key insights into virus transmission among elementary school students.
Setsuya Kurahashi, S. Kikuchi, K. Nakajima, Y. Kato, T. Takizawa, J. Sugiyama, T. Mukai, Y. Kakizawa
― 5 min read
Table of Contents
Every year, many people around the world get sick because of viruses that affect the respiratory system. These viruses can cause serious health problems and even lead to death. They also create big economic costs for society. Sometimes, there are pandemics, which are widespread outbreaks of illness, like the COVID-19 pandemic and the 2009 H1N1 flu outbreak. These pandemics have disrupted daily life and hurt economies.
Viruses spread in two main ways. The first way is through droplets, which are tiny drops of liquid that come out when a person coughs, sneezes, or talks. These droplets can be big or small. The second way is through contact with surfaces that have the virus on them. This can happen when a person touches something that has the virus on it, either directly or indirectly.
Schools are places where viruses can spread easily because Students and teachers are in close contact. When elementary school students get sick, they can also spread the virus to their families and communities. This makes it very important to study how viruses spread in elementary schools to prevent outbreaks.
Data Collection in Schools
To study virus Transmission in elementary schools, researchers need to gather information about students' behaviors related to how they interact. For droplet transmission, they need to know how long students talk to each other. For contact transmission, they need to know which items students touch and how often. Some previous research used surveys to collect this information, but surveys cannot capture all the details of what the students actually do. Other studies used wearable sensors, but those only detect when students are close to each other, not when they are talking.
In this study, researchers used video recordings to understand students' behaviors better. They recorded how students communicated and what items they touched. They observed the conversations and contact behaviors between students. By analyzing Communication patterns and contact items, the researchers predicted how viruses might be transmitted in the school.
Observation and Annotation
The study took place in a Tokyo elementary school, involving a class of 30 students aged 9 to 10. The researchers used multiple cameras to record the students during a four-day period in December 2022. They focused on breaks between classes when students were more likely to interact. To protect students' privacy, a third-party organization reviewed the videos and blurred the students' faces before the data was analyzed.
Communication behaviors were categorized into different types: conversations, physical contact, and instances where both occurred. Researchers recorded when communication started, who initiated it, how long it lasted, and which students were involved.
For contact behaviors, they noted when a student touched an item and who owned that item. Researchers recorded whether the student was alone or with others during these Contacts. They mapped out the classroom and hallways to understand the context of these interactions.
Communication Patterns
Researchers then created a network based on the communication behaviors of students. They tracked who talked to whom during the observation period. This network of communication helps illustrate how students interact with each other. They found that some students communicated more with certain peers, while others had less frequent interactions.
When analyzing the communication patterns, researchers observed that most interactions were brief and not very frequent. This finding points to the varied nature of communication among students. In some cases, a student may initiate a conversation, but the other student may not respond in kind, leading to an uneven communication dynamic.
Identifying Risks of Infection
The researchers calculated the risk of droplet infection based on the duration of conversations. They found that the probability of a student getting infected with the virus increased with longer conversations, especially if a virus carrier was involved.
In terms of contact behaviors, researchers looked at which items were touched and how often. They found that certain items, such as tables and doors, had a high number of contacts. This suggests these items could be significant in spreading the virus, especially if an infected person contacted them.
Micro-Simulation Analysis
To simulate and understand the potential for virus transmission, researchers conducted a micro-simulation based on the contact behaviors observed. They assumed that a virus-carrying student was present and recorded how many virus copies could be transferred to various surfaces.
During the simulations, items that students frequently contacted were identified as potential "fomites," or surfaces that could carry the virus. Researchers tracked how many virus copies were transferred when a student touched these items after contact with an infected individual.
The results showed that items like desks, serving tables, and doors had higher contact rates, indicating they could play a role in spreading the virus. The simulations demonstrated that a large number of virus copies could be transmitted through just one item, stressing the importance of cleaning and disinfecting commonly used surfaces in schools.
Conclusion
This study offers valuable insights into how viruses spread in elementary schools through communication and contact behaviors. The findings emphasize the importance of understanding student interactions to create effective strategies for reducing virus transmission.
By analyzing communication patterns and contact behaviors, researchers can identify high-risk items and interactions. This understanding can help schools develop better infection control measures, such as increasing awareness about hand hygiene and disinfecting surfaces.
Overall, this research contributes to the body of knowledge about infectious diseases in schools and can inform future efforts to prevent COVID-19 and other virus outbreaks among students.
Title: Quantification of droplet and contact transmission risks among elementary school students based on network analyses using video-recorded data
Abstract: Elementary schools are environments in which immunologically immature students come into close contact with each other and are susceptible to the spread of infectious diseases. Analyzing the behavior of multiple students has been challenging, and the relationship between infections remains unclear. In this study, we analyzed the relevance between droplet and contact transmission and the behavior of elementary school students using video-recorded data, network analyses, and simulations. The analysis of communication behavior revealed the diverse nature of interactions among students. By calculating the droplet transmission probabilities based on conversation duration, this study quantified the risk of droplet transmission in elementary schools. The analysis of contact behavior introduces a novel approach for constructing contact networks based on contact history. According to this method, items such as desks, shirts, and doors have the potential to be used as fomites for virus transmission. In addition, the reliability of the predictions was demonstrated through micro-simulations. Interestingly, the micro-simulations indicated that the majority of virus copies were transmitted through single items, emphasizing the importance of targeted hygiene measures. This study contributes significantly to the prevention of infectious diseases in elementary schools by providing evidence-based information on transmission pathways and behavior-related risks. Moreover, the insights from this study can guide the development of simulation models for analyzing infection risks in educational settings.
Authors: Setsuya Kurahashi, S. Kikuchi, K. Nakajima, Y. Kato, T. Takizawa, J. Sugiyama, T. Mukai, Y. Kakizawa
Last Update: 2024-10-27 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.10.25.24316099
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.10.25.24316099.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.