New Insights into Blazars: Quasars vs. BL Lacs
Study reveals key differences between quasars and BL Lac objects.
Janhavi Baghel, P. Kharb, T. Hovatta, Luis C. Ho, C. Harrison, E. Lindfors, Silpa S., S. Gulati
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
Active galactic nuclei (AGN) are galaxies with very active centers where a supermassive black hole is munching on gas and dust. This process generates a lot of energy and can launch jets of particles away from the black hole. These jets can be quite powerful and affect their host galaxy. There are different types of AGN, including radio-loud (RL) AGN which have strong jets that broadcast in radio waves.
Radio-loud AGN are further split into categories based on how they look. Some have a more spread-out appearance (called FRI) while others have a tighter, more focused look (FRII). The reason for these differences is a hot topic among scientists. The current thinking is that these characteristics might arise from how the jets are created or how they interact with their surroundings.
Within the realm of radio-loud AGN, there are two main types called Quasars and BL Lac objects, both of which are classified as blazars due to their jets pointing towards us. Quasars are known for having bright emission lines, while BL Lacs have weaker lines, making them trickier to study.
The main goal of our study was to take a closer look at a specific set of blazars from a well-known survey called the Palomar-Green (PG) sample. We wanted to delve into the differences in their properties using a method called Polarization, which helps us see how the jets are operating.
The Blazar Family
The blazar family is quite diverse, with their jets creating unique appearances. Quasars often seem more chaotic and can show signs of activity that suggest they've had some rough interactions with their environment. They can also change their appearance over time, showing off different shapes and brightness levels.
In contrast, BL Lac objects typically have a much smoother, more stable appearance. They often don't exhibit strong changes. Instead, they maintain a consistent level of activity which may hint at fewer violent interactions with the surrounding medium.
Study Setup
In this study, we used powerful radio telescopes to capture images of the jets from these blazars. We looked at 7 radio-loud quasars and 8 BL Lac objects, seeking to understand their properties and how they differ from one another.
We focused on kpc-scale polarization, examining how the jets behaved over a larger area. This is important because it allows us to see how the jets interact not just near the black hole but also further out in space where they can meet the surrounding material.
Observations
Using the Very Large Array (VLA) telescope, we collected images at a frequency of 6 GHz, allowing us to see fine details in the jets. We also used another telescope called the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (uGMRT) to provide additional data.
By applying a special technique called polarization calibration, we could understand the Magnetic Fields in the jets. This gives us clues about how the jets are structured and how they interact with the environment.
The Quasars
Among the 7 quasars we studied, we found that many displayed complex structures in their jets. For example, some showed signs of bends or hotspots, which are areas where the jet interacts with surrounding material. This can create interesting shapes and changes in brightness.
The polarization images revealed that many of the quasars had magnetic fields aligned with their jets. This suggests that the jets are well organized and structured, which might mean that the black holes at their centers are spinning in a particular way that allows for such organization.
The BL Lac Objects
In our exploration of the 8 BL Lac objects, we observed a variety of behaviors. While some displayed a core-halo structure (a bright center with a hazy outer region), others, like PG 1424+240 and PG 1437+398, had more diffuse emission.
The polarization data for the BL Lac objects indicated a more complicated magnetic field structure compared to the quasars. This suggests that their jets might be more affected by environmental interactions, leading to a variety of orientations of the magnetic fields.
Comparing the Two Groups
Upon comparing the quasars and BL Lac objects, we noted some interesting distinctions. The quasars tended to have a more organized magnetic structure consistent with strong jets, while the BL Lac objects showed greater variation in jet direction and magnetism.
This difference might suggest that the two types of blazars experience their environments in unique ways, possibly due to varying levels of energy output and interactions with surrounding material.
Polarization Patterns
Both blazar types displayed distinct polarization patterns. In the quasars, the magnetic fields were generally parallel to the jets, suggesting a consistent movement direction. In contrast, the BL Lac objects exhibited more chaotic behaviors, with some jets showing multiple orientations for their magnetic fields.
Interestingly, in some cases, the BL Lacs had jets that seemed to change direction over larger distances, indicating that their interactions with the surrounding medium might be more dynamic.
Environmental Connections
A key factor in the study is the role of the environment around these blazars. The jets interact with gas and dust as they travel through space. This interaction can lead to changes in jet structure and brightness and can also affect the magnetic fields present.
The findings hinted that the quasars might be less influenced by their environment compared to the BL Lacs. The BL Lac objects, on the other hand, seemed more affected by their surrounding material, which might explain their diverse appearances and magnetic field orientations.
Radio Morphology
The radio morphology - the shape and structure of the radio emissions - varied between the two types of blazars. The quasars often displayed a more chaotic morphology that suggested active jet systems capable of changing shape. The BL Lacs showed a more uniform structure with fewer dramatic changes, in line with their more stable behavior.
One of the notable features was the presence of hotspots in some of the quasars, which indicated interactions with the surrounding medium. These hotspots were often steep in spectral index, signifying active regions where the jet energy is released.
Implications
The different characteristics of the PG blazar sample suggest a broader story about how energy is transferred in these galaxies. The strength and organization of the jets, along with their interactions with the environment, can influence how galaxies evolve over time.
Understanding these differences can help astronomers better grasp the life cycles of galaxies. For instance, the data suggest that quasars might experience periodic bursts of activity, while BL Lacs tend to maintain steadier emissions.
Conclusion
Our study of the Palomar-Green blazar sample revealed a wealth of information about the differences and similarities between quasars and BL Lac objects. The findings highlighted how both types respond to their environments in unique ways, shaping their appearances and behaviors.
As we continue to explore the universe, the knowledge gained from these observations helps us piece together the puzzles of galaxy evolution and the role these active centers play in the grand scheme of things.
And who knows? Perhaps one day we'll find out that even in the vastness of space, there's a little bit of humor. After all, if black holes can gulp down gas like it’s a cosmic buffet, there’s got to be some fun in the universe somewhere!
Title: Investigating Differences in the Palomar-Green Blazar Population Using Polarization
Abstract: We present polarization images with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) in A and B-array configurations at 6 GHz of 7 radio-loud (RL) quasars and 8 BL Lac objects belonging to the Palomar-Green (PG) `blazar' sample. This completes our arcsecond-scale polarization study of an optically-selected volume-limited blazar sample comprising 16 radio-loud quasars and 8 BL Lac objects. Using the VLA, we identify kpc-scale polarization in the cores and jets/lobes of all the blazars, with fractional polarization varying from around $0.8 \pm 0.3$% to $37 \pm 6$%. The kpc-scale jets in PG RL quasars are typically aligned along their parsec-scale jets and show apparent magnetic fields parallel to jet directions in their jets/cores and magnetic field compression in their hotspots. The quasars show evidence of interaction with their environment as well as restarted AGN activity through morphology, polarization and spectral indices. These quasi-periodic jet modulations and restarted activity may be indicative of an unstable accretion disk undergoing transition. We find that the polarization characteristics of the BL Lacs are consistent with their jets being reoriented multiple times, with no correlation between their core apparent magnetic field orientations and pc-scale jet directions. We find that the low synchrotron peaked BL Lacs show polarization and radio morphology features typical of `strong' jet sources as defined by Meyer et al. (2011) for the `blazar envelope scenario', which posits a division based on jet profiles and velocity gradients rather than total jet power.
Authors: Janhavi Baghel, P. Kharb, T. Hovatta, Luis C. Ho, C. Harrison, E. Lindfors, Silpa S., S. Gulati
Last Update: 2024-11-11 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.06937
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.06937
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.