Simple Science

Cutting edge science explained simply

# Mathematics # Optimization and Control

Managing Uncertainty in Dynamic Systems

A look at how uncertainty affects engineering and science.

Amit Jain, Puneet Singla, Roshan Eapen

― 7 min read


Dynamic Systems and Dynamic Systems and Uncertainty dynamic systems. Techniques to manage uncertainty in
Table of Contents

Every time we drive a car or use a phone, we rely on systems working in the background. Sometimes, things go wrong, leading to problems we didn't expect. Imagine a car trying to navigate through a busy street. If a driver miscalculates the speed of a nearby vehicle or misjudges the traffic light, it can lead to a disaster. This is somewhat how uncertainty in dynamic systems works. Today, we’re taking a journey through the world of how we can manage and understand these uncertainties.

What is Uncertainty?

Uncertainty is just a fancy way of saying we don’t know everything. In engineering and science, it usually refers to the lack of complete knowledge about systems. For example, if you’re trying to predict the weather, you have to deal with uncertainties like changing temperatures and winds. In a similar way, when scientists and engineers work with dynamic systems-like spacecraft or robots-they need to deal with uncertainties too.

The Need for Uncertainty Propagation

Imagine baking a cake. You have a set recipe, but what if you accidentally added too much salt instead of sugar? You may still proceed but your cake would taste awful! The same principle applies to dynamic systems. If you have a system that behaves based on several changing factors, understanding how these changes impact the overall system is crucial. This is called uncertainty propagation.

When we talk about uncertainty propagation, we’re essentially trying to see how any small change in the input affects the final outcome. For instance, if the initial conditions of our system (like the starting speed or direction of a moving object) change even slightly, they can lead to major variations down the road. By learning to predict these changes, we can avoid surprises that might cause us trouble later.

Enter the Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov Equation

This is a mouthful, isn’t it? But hang in there! A fancy equation like the Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov (FPK) equation helps us analyze how the uncertainty spreads in a system over time. Think of it as a magical recipe that guides us on how our initial uncertainties will evolve based on the underlying dynamics of the system.

In simpler words, the FPK equation helps us track how our uncertainties transform over time, giving us an idea of what to expect in the future. But, as with any magical recipe, solving it can be quite tricky, especially when the system behaves in a nonlinear way-like a drunk person trying to walk straight.

The Challenge of High Dimensions

Using our cake analogy again, if you’re only working with a few ingredients, it’s easier to get everything right. But what if you were trying to combine a hundred different flavors? Each added flavor can introduce complexity, making it harder to balance the final taste. Similarly, in uncertainty propagation, if we deal with systems that have many interacting variables, we face what’s known as the curse of dimensionality.

As the number of variables increases, the amount of data we need to consider grows dramatically. Trying to solve high-dimensional problems becomes a computational nightmare. This is where a good strategy comes into play.

Sparse Collocation Methods

Instead of trying to handle everything at once, one way to simplify things is to use sparse collocation methods. Imagine you’re hosting a big party but only invite a handful of the best guests instead of every person you know. The same idea applies here; we want to pick the most important points in our system to get a good representation without drowning in complexity.

These methods help select specific points in the system’s space called collocation points. Instead of computing the behavior of the entire system, we focus on these key points, making our calculations much more manageable.

Choosing the Right Basis Functions

Just like picking the right guests for your party, picking the right basis functions is crucial in our analysis. Basis functions are like the building blocks used to predict the behavior of a system. You can think of them as the key ingredients for our uncertainty recipe.

Different types of basis functions are available, and selecting the right ones can greatly affect the outcome. If you pick the wrong ingredients, you might end up with a cake that no one wants to eat. In our case, the goal is to find a mix of basis functions that can accurately represent the uncertainty of the system.

The Role of Hamiltonian Functions

To make things even spicier, we can include Hamiltonian functions in our recipe. What is that? Think of it as a special ingredient that represents the total energy of our dynamic system. By incorporating Hamiltonians, we can better capture the underlying dynamics and keep our predictions accurate.

This concept comes from classical mechanics. By including Hamiltonian in the mix, we can create a more robust basis function dictionary. This ensures that we capture not only the immediate uncertainty but also how it evolves over time.

The Application of the Method

Now that we have our recipe in hand, let’s try baking some cakes, or in our case, applying this method to real-life systems.

Duffing Oscillator

One of the first tests we perform is on a dynamical system known as the Duffing oscillator. This oscillator can sway back and forth and has a fun, unpredictable nature, much like someone trying to balance on a swing. By applying our uncertainty propagation technique, we can track the changes in the oscillator's response over time.

As we adjust the parameters and observe the behavior, the results help confirm whether our recipe is delivering the desired results. When everything comes together, we see that the predicted outcomes align well with our expectations.

Two-Body Problem

Next, we tackle a more complex problem involving two bodies, like two orbiting planets. Just like our earlier cake example, the initial states of these two bodies matter a lot. Small changes in their paths can lead to very different orbits.

Here, we can use our sparse collocation method to propagate the uncertainties in their motions and analyze how they influence each other. By applying the techniques we’ve honed, we can gain insights into how these two celestial bodies will interact over time.

Orbit Transfer Maneuver

For our final act, we consider a scenario of a satellite performing a maneuver between orbits. It’s like a dancer performing a beautiful dance while trying to time her moves perfectly. The satellite needs to execute a series of burns at just the right time to transition smoothly from one position to another.

In this situation, we utilize our uncertainty propagation technique to predict how uncertainties in its position and velocity can impact the maneuver. This analysis allows engineers to make better decisions and minimize risks associated with maneuvering in space.

Conclusion

To wrap things up, our exploration into uncertainty propagation in dynamic systems has taken us on quite a journey. We’ve seen how uncertainty can be managed through powerful equations, chosen basis functions, and methods to simplify complex systems.

Just like in cooking, careful selection of ingredients can drastically change the outcome. By weaving in Hamiltonians and utilizing sparse collocation techniques, we can navigate the tricky waters of uncertainty more effectively.

Whether we're baking cakes or sending satellites into space, understanding and managing uncertainty remains a crucial task in our ever-evolving world. So, let’s raise a toast (or a cake) to managing uncertainty like the pros we aspire to be!

More from authors

Similar Articles