Balancing Goals in Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning
A new approach to ensure fairness in multi-objective decision-making.
Dimitris Michailidis, Willem Röpke, Diederik M. Roijers, Sennay Ghebreab, Fernando P. Santos
― 5 min read
Table of Contents
- What is MORL?
- The Challenge of Fairness
- Introducing Lorenz Dominance
- The New Algorithm
- A Real-World Testbed: Transport Planning
- Learning From the Environment
- Why is MORL Important?
- The Competition
- Experiments and Results
- Setting Up the Challenge
- Performance Metrics
- Results Overview
- Flexible Fairness with -Lorenz Dominance
- Conclusion
- Original Source
- Reference Links
Welcome to the fascinating world of Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning (MORL). Picture this: you’re trying to teach a robot to make decisions that benefit everyone involved, not just one group. This task gets tricky when there are many groups involved, each with different needs. MORL comes into play by helping the robot figure out how to best meet these varied needs while keeping things fair.
What is MORL?
MORL is like a tricky game where you must juggle multiple things at once. Imagine you are a tightrope walker. You need to balance while also making sure you don't fall and that the audience enjoys the show. Similarly, MORL helps agents balance different goals, such as satisfying multiple groups while also achieving a good end result.
Fairness
The Challenge ofWhen we talk about fairness, we mean that no group should feel left out or overlooked. In real life, some rewards may be skewed in favor of one group over another. For example, think about a town's budget for the playground: should more money go to the park in the wealthy part of town, or should it be equally divided among all neighborhoods? MORL helps address this kind of question.
Introducing Lorenz Dominance
You might ask, how do we keep things fair? We introduce a concept called Lorenz dominance. This idea is similar to saying one group should not get a larger piece of the pie than others. Lorenz dominance helps to keep the rewards more evenly distributed, making sure everyone gets a fair slice of the pie!
The New Algorithm
The new algorithm we propose incorporates fairness into MORL while still being efficient. We use our version of Lorenz dominance, which allows for flexible rules on how fairness works. This way, decision-makers can adjust their preferences, like choosing different flavors of ice cream.
A Real-World Testbed: Transport Planning
To see how well our algorithm performs, we created a large-scale environment for planning Transport Networks in cities. Think of it as creating a public transport system that everyone can use fairly. We tested our algorithm in two cities, Xi'an and Amsterdam, which have their unique challenges and needs.
Learning From the Environment
MORL relies on agents that learn from their environment. Imagine a puppy learning to sit. It tries different things until it finds the right behavior. Agents in our approach do something similar, learning to optimize their actions based on the feedback they receive from different objectives.
Why is MORL Important?
MORL isn't just for robots or engineers; it can help in various fields. For instance, city planners can use it to design transportation systems that cater to different communities without bias. In a world that often seems divided, this technology offers a way to bring people together. Everyone gets their fair share without the need for an endless debate about who deserves what.
The Competition
In the world of MORL, several Algorithms are already in play. However, they often struggle with scaling up their efforts efficiently. Our new method, Lorenz Conditioned Networks (LCN), aims to overcome these challenges. Think of it as providing a supercharged toolbox for solving complex problems while ensuring fairness.
Experiments and Results
We put our algorithm to the test, and the results were promising. In various scenarios, LCN consistently outperformed other methods. It’s like finding the perfect sauce that just makes the entire dish come together!
Setting Up the Challenge
The experiments were designed to mirror real-world scenarios. We created a large multi-objective environment where the agent had to decide on the best approach to design transport networks. Think of it as being a city planner with the responsibility of connecting neighborhoods.
Performance Metrics
To measure how well our algorithm did, we looked at several factors:
- Hypervolume: This is like measuring how much space our solutions occupy compared to a goal.
- Expected Utility Metric: This assesses how beneficial each solution is.
- Sen Welfare: This combines both efficiency and equality to see how well we served everyone.
Results Overview
In our results, LCN proved itself in balancing the needs across all objectives while still generating efficient solutions. It's kind of like a group project where everyone contributes equally without someone stealing the show!
Flexible Fairness with -Lorenz Dominance
One of the unique features of our approach is the flexibility it offers. By adjusting a single parameter, decision-makers can choose how much emphasis they want to place on fairness versus optimality. This flexibility is akin to choosing the right settings on your washing machine for the best results.
Conclusion
To wrap it all up, our new method for tackling multi-objective reinforcement learning with fairness guarantees holds great promise. Not only does it help in making decisions that benefit everyone fairly, but it also scales efficiently to meet complex real-world challenges.
As we continue down this exciting path, we hope to further refine these methods, bringing us closer to equitable solutions in various fields while ensuring that no one feels left behind. The journey may be long, but it’s definitely worth taking!
Title: Scalable Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning with Fairness Guarantees using Lorenz Dominance
Abstract: Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning (MORL) aims to learn a set of policies that optimize trade-offs between multiple, often conflicting objectives. MORL is computationally more complex than single-objective RL, particularly as the number of objectives increases. Additionally, when objectives involve the preferences of agents or groups, ensuring fairness is socially desirable. This paper introduces a principled algorithm that incorporates fairness into MORL while improving scalability to many-objective problems. We propose using Lorenz dominance to identify policies with equitable reward distributions and introduce {\lambda}-Lorenz dominance to enable flexible fairness preferences. We release a new, large-scale real-world transport planning environment and demonstrate that our method encourages the discovery of fair policies, showing improved scalability in two large cities (Xi'an and Amsterdam). Our methods outperform common multi-objective approaches, particularly in high-dimensional objective spaces.
Authors: Dimitris Michailidis, Willem Röpke, Diederik M. Roijers, Sennay Ghebreab, Fernando P. Santos
Last Update: 2024-11-27 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.18195
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.18195
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.
Reference Links
- https://github.com/sias-uva/mo-transport-network-design
- https://github.com/dimichai/mo-tndp
- https://github.com/weiyu123112/City-Metro-Network-Expansion-with-RL
- https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/maatwerk/2019/31/kerncijfers-wijken-en-buurten-2019
- https://aware-night-ab1.notion.site/Project-B-MO-LCN-Experiment-Tracker-b4d21ab160eb458a9cff9ab9314606a7