Simple Science

Cutting edge science explained simply

# Physics # Earth and Planetary Astrophysics # Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

The Longevity of Protoplanetary Disks

New findings reveal protoplanetary disks may last longer than previously thought.

Wataru Ooyama, Riouhei Nakatani, Takashi Hosokawa, Hiroto Mitani, Neal J. Turner

― 5 min read


Longevity of Cosmic Disks Longevity of Cosmic Disks longer than expected. Protoplanetary disks may sustain gas
Table of Contents

When we look at the Stars and their surroundings, we see something fascinating: disks of dust and gas swirling around them, like cosmic pancakes. These disks are not just for decoration; they can help create planets. But there's a twist: it seems some of these disks have a knack for hanging around longer than we thought.

What Are Protoplanetary Disks?

Picture a young star, fresh and bright, with a swirling disk of gas and dust around it. These are called protoplanetary disks, the birthplace of planets. Over time, we expected these disks to fade away within a few million years. But recent discoveries have thrown that idea into a spin. Some disks still have gas! It's like finding out your favorite old movie still has new scenes no one knew about.

The Mystery of the Gas

The big question is: where is this gas coming from? One idea suggests that some of these disks might be surviving longer than we thought. It’s like a surprise birthday party that goes on for years. To investigate this, scientists ran computer models to simulate how these disks evolve over time. They tweaked things like the size of the star and the amount of gas, trying to understand how these disks can stick around.

What Keeps the Gas?

The researchers focused on disks that had lost a lot of small Particles. These particles usually get blown away by the Sun's light, but when they are less abundant, disks can hang on to their gas longer. The models showed that if a disk starts out heavy enough and has a gentle breeze of turbulence, the gas can last a lot longer.

What Did They Find?

The simulations revealed that larger disks can keep their gas much longer, even up to several million years! The researchers found out that it doesn't matter how massive the star is; what's important is how substantial the disk is at the beginning. They even noticed that the gas in these disks is similar in amount to what’s found in some star systems with more gas than dust.

The Accretion Surprise

Another interesting bit is that as long as the gas stays, it seems to keep Feeding into the star. Think of it as a never-ending buffet — as long as the leftovers are there, the party keeps going. Detecting this ongoing feeding frenzy might give clues to the disk's origins. Scientists have spotted a few of these "gas-rich" disks, where the gas is a sign that something is cooking.

Why Does This Matter?

Understanding how these disks last is essential. If they hang around longer, they might produce more gas giants — those big, fluffy planets like Jupiter. This knowledge can help explain the variety of planets we see in the universe.

The Two Scenarios

When it comes to explaining the gas, there are two main ideas floating around. One is that the gas is leftovers from the original protoplanetary disk. This means some disks survived way longer than scientists previously estimated. The second idea is that the gas is created later on, maybe from collisions of smaller space rocks.

Historically, the first idea seemed unlikely, so researchers focused on the second one. However, some researchers recently revisited the first idea and found ways that protoplanetary disks could survive longer. When they looked at the disks again with new eyes, they discovered that if the right conditions are met, these disks could last much longer.

Learning From The Models

To learn more, researchers used different models. They created computer simulations to see how disks behave under various conditions — kind of like cooking with different recipes. They tested how the disks would react to different amounts of gas, dust, and even how the star shone.

The Big Picture

The ultimate goal of all this research is to understand how disks evolve over time and what this means for the planets that form in them. The more we learn about these disks, the better we can understand the universe and our place in it.

Looking Ahead

As researchers continue this exploration, the quest to find evidence for longer-lasting protoplanetary disks will remain a priority. Searching for signs of ongoing gas feeding in these disks could become a game-changer. If scientists find more gas-rich disks, it could support the idea that they originated from surviving protoplanetary disks.

Connecting the Dots

This research digs deep into the origins of different types of planets. By uncovering the secrets of protoplanetary disks, we learn how planetary systems evolve over time, helping piece together the cosmic puzzle that is our universe.

Final Thoughts

In the end, the universe continues to surprise us. Just when we think we've got it all figured out, new discoveries emerge. With every new finding, we inch closer to understanding not just how stars and planets form, but also the intricate dance of matter in space.

So the next time you gaze up at the stars, remember there’s a whole lot more going on in those twinkling lights, and some of it involves dusty disks hanging around longer than expected, just waiting to tell their story.

Original Source

Title: Secret of Longevity: Protoplanetary Disks as a Source of Gas in Debris Disk

Abstract: While protoplanetary disks (PPDs) are generally thought to dissipate within several Myr, recent observations have revealed gas in debris disks. The origin of this gas remains uncertain, with one possibility being the unexpectedly long survival of PPDs (the primordial-origin scenario). To explore the plausibility of this scenario, we conduct 1D disk evolution simulations, varying parameters like stellar mass, disk mass, turbulent stress, and magnetohydrodynamic winds, while incorporating stellar evolution to account for time-varying photoevaporation rates. Our focus is on disks where small grains are depleted, as these are potentially long-lived due to reduced far-ultraviolet photoevaporation. Our results show that gas in these disks can survive beyond 10 Myr regardless of the stellar mass, provided they are initially massive ($M_{\mathrm{disk}}\approx 0.1M_*$) with relatively weak turbulent stress ($\alpha \ll 10^{-2}$). The longest lifetimes are consistently found for $M_* = 2 M_{\odot}$ across a wide parameter space, with gas typically persisting at $\sim 10$--$10^3 \mathrm{au}$. Roughly estimated CO masses for these disks fall within the observed range for the most massive gas-rich debris disks around early A stars. These alignments support the plausibility of the primordial-origin scenario. Additionally, our model predicts that accretion persists for as long as the disk survives, which could explain the accretion signatures detected in old disks hosted by low-mass stars, including Peter Pan disks. Our finding also suggests that ongoing accretion may exist in gas-rich debris disks. Thus, searching for accretion signatures could be a key factor to identifying the origin of gas in debris disks.

Authors: Wataru Ooyama, Riouhei Nakatani, Takashi Hosokawa, Hiroto Mitani, Neal J. Turner

Last Update: 2024-11-26 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.17114

Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.17114

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

Similar Articles