Simple Science

Cutting edge science explained simply

# Biology # Neuroscience

The Impact of Time on Learning and Self-Belief

Discover how timing affects our learning and self-perception.

Annalina V. Mayer, Alexander Schröder, Nora Czekalla, Laura Müller-Pinzler, Laura Rosenbusch, Frieder M. Paulus, Henrik Oster, Clara Sayk, Mathias Kammerer, Ines Wilhelm-Groch, Sören Krach

― 8 min read


Timing Matters in Timing Matters in Learning self-belief. Explore how time affects learning and
Table of Contents

Humans are creatures of habit, and one of the most interesting habits we have is how our brains work at different times of the day. Just like your morning coffee helps you wake up, the time you choose to learn something can also determine how well you understand it. Yes, that's right! The clock can play a role in how smart you feel.

Cognitive Functions and the Time of Day

When we talk about cognitive functions, we mean all those brainy tasks that help us pay attention, remember things, and make decisions. Your brain doesn't function the same way at 8 AM as it does at 8 PM. Research shows that our attention tends to dip during nighttime and early morning hours. In layman's terms, if you’re trying to read a book or solve a problem at 3 AM, good luck!

Instead, we get a boost around noon and feel most alive in the afternoon and evening. It’s almost as if the sun is our personal cheerleader, keeping us sharp and focused. Interestingly, this pattern also applies to memory and executive functions, which are fancy words for decision-making and problem-solving skills. If you’ve ever experienced what we call a “brain fog” early in the morning, you’re not alone!

Learning and Time

While we know a lot about how time affects attention and memory, we haven’t fully understood how it impacts learning itself. Learning can be tricky because it involves many different tasks and ways to measure success, making it hard to get a clear picture.

Take the task of learning sequences, for instance. Studies have shown that if you try to learn something in the evening, your performance might take a nosedive. That’s not the kind of dive you want to see, especially not when learning is involved! Older adults sometimes show lots of variability in their learning in the evening, while younger folks seem to manage just fine.

School students often perform better on tests taken in the morning, suggesting that the early bird might indeed get the worm-or at least, better grades! This points to the idea that the time of day does have a say in how well we learn, though the exact details remain a bit fuzzy.

Emotions and the Time of Day

Now, it’s not just our brains that follow a daily rhythm; our emotions do too! Think about how your mood changes throughout the day. According to some studies, we tend to feel more positive as the day goes on, peaking in the afternoon and giving a slight dip at night. So, if you’ve been feeling more cheerful while scrolling through your social media feed in the evening, it could be because you’re riding that wave of positive feelings.

Young people, like adolescents, have also shown improvements in mood throughout the school day. It’s a bit like a mood rollercoaster, but hopefully a smooth ride! Our ability to feel and handle emotions is influenced by the time of day, and getting enough sleep or being in a good state of mind can really change the game.

Self-Belief Formation: What Are We Talking About?

Now, let’s zoom in on the concept of self-belief formation. This fancy term is just a way of describing how we understand ourselves based on the feedback we receive from the world around us. Think of it as how we form opinions about our appearance, skills, or popularity.

Self-beliefs can change when people experience good or bad feedback. For example, if you nail that presentation at work, your self-belief might get a big boost. On the other hand, if it flops, you might feel like a train wreck.

The tricky part? How we adjust those beliefs can change based on our mood and the time of day. When feeling positive, we tend to view ourselves in a more favorable light. In contrast, on a bad day, we might be more critical of ourselves. So, if you’re questioning your self-worth at 2 AM, it’s no wonder!

Why Timing Matters for Self-Belief Formation

So, why does time become crucial in forming our beliefs about ourselves? Well, for starters, if our cognitive functions and emotions fluctuate throughout the day, then it stands to reason that our ability to form self-beliefs would vary as well.

To explore this idea, researchers combined data from five different studies that investigated self-belief formation. They looked at people who were asked to complete tasks at various times of the day. The goal? To see if the time of day affected how strongly these individuals updated their beliefs about themselves.

The Learning Task: LOOP

The method involved a task called the Learning of Own Performance Task, or LOOP for short. It’s a performance-based learning task where participants receive feedback based on how well they estimate different things, like the weight of a cow or the height of a building. It’s like a game that allows them to form new beliefs about their abilities.

Each round involves guessing, followed by feedback about how close they were to the right answer. In a perfect world, you’d learn to get better over time. But how well you learn can depend on what time of day it is.

Participants who tackled this task received feedback that was rigged to ensure one category of tasks had more positive feedback while another had more negative feedback. This setup was designed to assess how feedback changes self-belief formation throughout the day.

The Big Findings: What Did We Learn?

Delving into the data revealed some interesting insights. Learning Rates, or how quickly people updated their self-beliefs in response to feedback, varied by time of day. There was a noticeable increase in learning rates in the evening compared to the afternoon. In other words, if you want to feel great about your skills, consider doing it after dinner!

Interestingly, the findings also pointed out how negative feedback resulted in stronger adjustments to self-beliefs. It seems we’re wired to respond more powerfully to criticism than to praise. So, you might feel like you’re on top of the world after a compliment, but a single piece of bad news can stick with you like gum on the bottom of a shoe.

The Non-Linear Nature of Learning

While the results hinted at a simple correlation between time and self-belief formation, they also suggested that these changes might not follow a straightforward path. There appeared to be rhythmic fluctuations in how learning rates changed throughout the day. Think of it like waves in the ocean-sometimes calm, sometimes crashing.

These conclusions hint at potentially complex patterns influenced by our mood, cognitive performance, and even external factors such as sleep quality. If you’ve ever felt tired after a long day and struggled to learn something new, it’s not all in your head. You really could have been fighting an uphill battle!

What Does This Mean for You?

So, why should you care about when you learn and how you think about yourself? Well, understanding how time impacts self-belief formation can offer valuable insights, especially in areas like therapy or education.

For instance, if you're in therapy trying to improve your self-image, understanding that evenings might be more beneficial for these discussions could lead to better outcomes. It’s like having a flashlight in a dark room; it helps illuminate the path to healthier self-beliefs.

Similarly, educators can use this knowledge to schedule learning tasks more effectively. If students learn better in the morning, then afternoons could be reserved for less demanding tasks. Simple adjustments could make a world of difference.

Future Directions: What’s Next?

The research highlights the importance of further studies that can dive deeper into this fascinating topic. Future research could compare the same individuals at various times of the day to see exactly how their self-belief formation changes over time.

Additionally, factors like chronotype-the natural inclination to be a morning or evening person-could play a big role. Including these nuances may help create a clearer picture of when and how people best update their self-beliefs.

Sleep quality, mood, and personal preferences all have an important place in this conversation. If we can better understand these complexities, we might just unlock the key to helping individuals form stronger, healthier self-beliefs.

Conclusion: Time Is of the Essence

In summary, the time of day significantly influences not just how well we learn but also how we perceive ourselves. Our cognitive functions and emotional states ripple throughout the day, shaping the way we form and update our self-beliefs.

From helping students ace their tests to guiding people through the journey of self-discovery in therapy, recognizing these rhythms can lead to better outcomes.

So, the next time you’re looking to learn something new or boost your confidence, remember: timing is everything. If you want to feel smart, consider studying in the afternoon. Better yet, celebrate your victories and face your challenges in the evening-your brain and beliefs will thank you!

Original Source

Title: Time-of-day related fluctuations of self-belief formation

Abstract: Time of day influences a variety of human cognitive processes, including attention, executive functions and memory formation, as well as affective experiences and mood. However, circadian modulations of self-related learning and belief formation, which are highly affected by emotional states, remain poorly understood. Here, we present results from exploratory post-hoc analyses on data aggregated from five studies assessing the formation of self-related ability beliefs. A total of N=242 healthy participants completed a validated learning task at different times of the day, during which they continuously received feedback on their performance. Computational modeling was applied to quantify participants learning behavior during the task. Results suggest an association between time-of-day and self-belief formation, showing that participants who were tested in the evening (7:00-9:59 p.m.) updated their self-beliefs more strongly in response to the received feedback compared to those tested in the afternoon (1:00-3:59 p.m.). Evidence from additional models indicated that these differences were driven by non-linear, rhythmic changes in self-belief formation across different times of the day. Future studies should systematically examine within-subject fluctuations in self-belief formation across the day and address the influence of individual factors such as chronotype, age, mood and sleep quality. Understanding circadian modulations of self-related belief formation could contribute to optimized interventions for conditions characterized by maladaptive self-beliefs, such as depression, as well as in academic contexts.

Authors: Annalina V. Mayer, Alexander Schröder, Nora Czekalla, Laura Müller-Pinzler, Laura Rosenbusch, Frieder M. Paulus, Henrik Oster, Clara Sayk, Mathias Kammerer, Ines Wilhelm-Groch, Sören Krach

Last Update: Dec 9, 2024

Language: English

Source URL: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.05.627011

Source PDF: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.05.627011.full.pdf

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to biorxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

Similar Articles