The Essential Role of SBOMs in Software Security
Learn how SBOMs protect software from hidden vulnerabilities.
Can Ozkan, Xinhai Zou, Dave Singelee
― 7 min read
Table of Contents
- What is an SBOM?
- The Rise of SBOMs
- How SBOMs Work
- The Legal Bits
- The Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC)
- Connections Between SBOM and SDLC
- Potential Security Issues with SBOMs
- Attack Scenarios
- The Importance of Integrity in SBOMs
- Current Practices in SBOM Consumption and Generation
- The Findings
- Proposed Solutions
- Linking SBOMs to Actual Software
- The Future of Security with SBOMs
- Decentralized Systems
- Conclusion
- Original Source
In today’s world, Software is everywhere. From the apps on our phones to the systems managing our power grids, software plays a vital role in our daily lives. However, with this reliance comes a risk: Vulnerabilities in software can lead to significant Security issues. This is where Software Bills of Materials (SBOM) come into play. You might think of SBOMs as a recipe list that details what ingredients (or software components) go into a dish (or software product).
If you think that sounds boring, let’s spice it up: imagine biting into your favorite cake only to find it was made with expired ingredients. Yikes! That’s the kind of surprise you don’t want when it comes to software.
What is an SBOM?
At its core, an SBOM is a list that shows all the parts that make up a piece of software. This includes libraries, dependencies, and other components, much like a food label lists the ingredients in your snacks. Having this transparency helps organizations ensure that the software they’re using is safe and compliant with licensing requirements. Think of it as a shield against the hidden ingredients that could cause trouble later on.
The Rise of SBOMs
The increasing reliance on third-party software has led to the creation and adoption of SBOMs. The government and various organizations have realized that they need to keep track of their software components to mitigate risks related to cyber-attacks. For instance, the SolarWinds attack was a wake-up call. Pretty much everyone in the industry realized they needed to get their act together regarding software transparency.
How SBOMs Work
So, how does this all work? An SBOM provides a detailed inventory of all the software components in an application. It’s like a detailed map that allows organizations to monitor and manage their software dependencies and vulnerabilities.
The Legal Bits
In the U.S., the government has made sure that suppliers of software provide an SBOM for any software they sell to federal agencies. This move is part of a broader effort to improve software security, and it’s no laughing matter. The executive order aims to put safeguards in place to prevent the disastrous consequences of the next software breach.
The Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC)
Before we get too far, it’s essential to understand the Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC). This refers to the process of developing software from start to finish.
- Requirement: Gather what the software should do. Think of it as asking “What do I want for dinner?”
- Design: Deciding on the architecture and components. This is like planning your menu.
- Implementation: This is where the coding happens, akin to cooking the meal.
- Testing: Validating that the software works as intended. Think of this as tasting the dish.
- Deployment: Releasing the software to users. It’s like serving the food.
- Maintenance: Updating and fixing any issues that come up over time, just like cleaning up after dinner.
Connections Between SBOM and SDLC
An SBOM is closely tied to the SDLC. During each phase of the software development process, an SBOM can help track all components and ensure they meet security and licensing requirements. This connection makes the SBOM a critical element for maintaining software Integrity.
Imagine a dinner party where you keep track of every ingredient in your dishes and ensure none of them are expired. If one ingredient turns out to be a little fishy, you can quickly substitute it with something fresh before serving, ensuring your guests are safe and happy.
Potential Security Issues with SBOMs
While having an SBOM is crucial, it’s not foolproof. There are some sneaky ways that bad actors can manipulate SBOMs, which could undermine their integrity. For instance, attackers can alter software components or dependencies in such a way that vulnerabilities go unnoticed.
Attack Scenarios
There are three primary attack scenarios during the SBOM lifecycle:
-
During SBOM Generation: If attackers gain access to the software code, they can mislead the SBOM generation process. It’s like hiding an expired ingredient in the middle of your dish.
-
Throughout SBOM Distribution: If an attacker can tamper with the communication between the supplier and consumer, they could spoof consumers with incorrect SBOMs. You don’t want a fake food label, do you?
-
During SBOM Storage: If attackers can access stored SBOMs, they can alter the information, making it unreliable for consumers. It’s akin to swapping out a good brand of apples for rotten ones in the grocery store.
The Importance of Integrity in SBOMs
To mitigate these risks, organizations must maintain the integrity of SBOMs. This means having robust verification mechanisms in place to ensure that the data is accurate and hasn’t been tampered with. Imagine a food inspector checking your kitchen to make sure everything is safe to eat. That’s what integrity control does for software.
Current Practices in SBOM Consumption and Generation
Currently, many tools used for SBOM consumption and generation are not equipped to effectively handle integrity verification. Most of them depend mainly on version numbers to identify vulnerabilities, but they overlook key elements like hash values, leaving a gaping hole in security.
The Findings
Analyzing various SBOM consumption tools revealed that none had cryptographic controls for validating dependencies. This means that if someone tampered with the numbers, the tools would be none the wiser. It’s like a store that checks if your apples look good but never tests them for freshness.
Proposed Solutions
To tackle these security concerns, we propose a three-part solution that focuses on:
-
Secure Distribution: Ensuring that SBOMs are transmitted securely, much like using a reliable delivery service for your groceries.
-
Secure Storage: Protecting SBOMs from unauthorized access, akin to locking up your pantry to avoid unwelcome guests.
-
Decentralized Hash Storage: Establishing a system that allows for the verification and validation of SBOMs, much like having a trusted source for confirming the freshness of ingredients.
Linking SBOMs to Actual Software
Connecting SBOMs to the actual software they represent can be challenging. Currently, SBOMs often use version names instead of hash values, which weakens the relationship between the two. The goal should be to compute hashes for software components and tie them directly to their SBOM entries.
Imagine if every time you bought a product with a barcode, you could scan it and confirm its quality. That’s what we’re aiming for with SBOM integrity!
The Future of Security with SBOMs
Building a robust system for linking SBOMs and the software they represent will require innovative solutions. We can take inspiration from existing technologies, like certificate transparency and blockchain, to create a decentralized system for managing software hashes.
Decentralized Systems
The idea is simple yet powerful: create a public repository of software hashes that anyone can verify. This would enhance accountability and allow organizations to trust their software components. It’s like having a public record of every dish ever served, so you can check who made it, what went into it, and whether it’s safe to eat.
Blockchain and Certificate Transparency
By leveraging blockchain, we can establish a decentralized and immutable record of software ownership, ensuring developers can confirm their software’s integrity. Much like how you can track the origins of organic food, this process offers transparency and security for software.
Conclusion
In the vast world of software, having a solid understanding of software components and their dependencies is crucial for maintaining cybersecurity. SBOMs can play a significant role in ensuring that software is safe and compliant with licensing requirements.
However, organizations must take extra steps to secure their SBOMs from potential tampering and ensure that the data remains accurate and trustworthy. By implementing robust verification mechanisms and creating decentralized systems for managing software hashes, we can significantly enhance supply chain security.
Ultimately, just like a well-organized kitchen leads to great meals, having a well-maintained SBOM can lead to safe and secure software. And who doesn’t want to enjoy their tech without the worry of unexpected surprises?
Original Source
Title: Supply Chain Insecurity: The Lack of Integrity Protection in SBOM Solutions
Abstract: The SolarWinds attack that exploited weaknesses in the software update mechanism highlights the critical need for organizations to have better visibility into their software dependencies and potential vulnerabilities associated with them, and the Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) is paramount in ensuring software supply chain security. Under the Executive Order issued by President Biden, the adoption of the SBOM has become obligatory within the United States. The executive order mandates that an SBOM should be provided for all software purchased by federal agencies. The main applications of SBOMs are vulnerability management and license management. This work presents an in-depth and systematic investigation into the integrity of SBOMs. We explore different attack vectors that can be exploited to manipulate SBOM data, including flaws in the SBOM generation and consumption phases in the SBOM life cycle. We thoroughly investigated four SBOM consumption tools and the generation process of SBOMs for seven prominent programming languages. Our systematic investigation reveals that the tools used for consumption lack integrity control mechanisms for dependencies. Similarly, the generation process is susceptible to integrity attacks as well, by manipulating dependency version numbers in package managers and additional files, resulting in incorrect SBOM data. This could lead to incorrect views on software dependencies and vulnerabilities being overlooked during SBOM consumption. To mitigate these issues, we propose a solution incorporating the decentralized storage of hash values of software libraries.
Authors: Can Ozkan, Xinhai Zou, Dave Singelee
Last Update: 2024-12-09 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.05138
Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2412.05138
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.