Digital Tools to Support Smoking Cessation
Utilizing technology for better smoking cessation support.
Corinna Leppin, Tosan Okpako, Claire Garnett, Olga Perski, Jamie Brown
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- The Current Situation
- What Are JITAIs?
- How Do They Collect Data?
- Why JITAIs Matter
- But, Are They Effective?
- What People Think About JITAIs
- The Research Approach
- How Were Participants Chosen?
- What Happened in the Focus Groups?
- Key Themes from the Discussions
- What Are The Key Takeaways?
- Social Support and Integration
- Privacy Concerns
- Future Directions
- Conclusion
- So, What’s Next?
- Original Source
- Reference Links
Smoking is a major health issue in the UK. Many people want to quit, but it’s not easy. In fact, smoking is linked to a lot of sickness and death. To help, we need better ways to Support those trying to quit. This is where digital tools come in. We can use technology to make quitting smoking easier and more effective.
The Current Situation
Smokers often find it hard to stay motivated and need help when cravings strike. Current methods of support can be slow or may not address the immediate needs of the individual. Many people might not reach out for help when they most need it, which can lead to setbacks or full relapses. What’s needed is a system that can provide help exactly when it is required, which is where just-in-time adaptive interventions (JITAIs) come in. Imagine having a buddy who knows just when to send you a text to cheer you on right when you feel like giving in.
What Are JITAIs?
JITAIs are a type of digital support specifically designed to give help at the right time. They work by using Data collected from the user to understand their needs and when they might need a push to stay on track. This data can come from surveys, phone sensors, or even heart-rate monitors. By finding out what a person is feeling at that moment, a JITAI can send helpful reminders and tips to keep them motivated or help them deal with cravings.
How Do They Collect Data?
To be effective, JITAIs gather a lot of information about users regularly. They can ask questions through surveys or use sensors to gather passive data. This means they can learn about a person's habits and feelings without them even having to actively share their thoughts. However, this raises questions about Privacy and security. After all, who wants their smoking habits broadcast to the world?
Why JITAIs Matter
Most current Smoking Cessation programs don’t quite hit the mark. They might help with general motivation but often miss the moment-to-moment struggles that a smoker faces. Plus, some people may not reach out for help when they really need it. JITAIs aim to fill this gap by providing tailored support exactly when it’s needed.
But, Are They Effective?
While JITAIs show promise, they’re still in the early stages of development. The existing ones are mainly available as apps, which can vary widely in terms of features and approach. Some may be super useful, while others could annoy users with too many notifications. Finding out how to make these tools truly useful and appealing to a wide audience is still a work in progress.
What People Think About JITAIs
Feedback from users and professionals in the field suggests that there is a lot of potential for JITAIs. Smokers and cessation professionals generally see them as useful when they fit seamlessly into a user’s life and provide real support. There’s a strong interest in the idea of personalizing these tools to fit individual needs, like mood or location.
The Research Approach
To learn more about what people think regarding JITAIs, researchers conducted focus groups with two groups of stakeholders: current smokers who want to quit and professionals who help people quit. The goal was to understand how JITAIs could fit into their lives and what features would be most helpful.
How Were Participants Chosen?
Most smokers were recruited through social media ads, while professionals were found through mailing lists associated with smoking cessation services. Participants had to answer a few questions to ensure they were a good fit for the study.
What Happened in the Focus Groups?
The focus groups provided a wealth of information. Participants shared their thoughts on the smoking cessation process, the features they valued in a JITAI, and their preferences for data sharing.
Key Themes from the Discussions
-
Smoking Cessation Process: Quitting smoking is not a straight line; it’s often messy and filled with ups and downs. Participants emphasized the need for a JITAI to accommodate this reality by providing ongoing support throughout the quitting process.
-
JITAI Characteristics: Smokers generally preferred using apps and wanted features that included notifications, multimedia content, and tools for self-reflection. The ability to customize the experience was noted as vital.
-
Perceived Value: Users want to feel that the JITAI makes a positive impact on their quitting journey. If it doesn’t work for them, they’ll likely stop using it.
-
Relationship with the JITAI: Smokers described wanting a supportive relationship with their JITAI, similar to that of a friend. They appreciated features that allowed them to maintain control, making sure the tool is available when needed but not overwhelming.
What Are The Key Takeaways?
The insights gathered indicate that developing a JITAI should focus on personalization and flexibility while ensuring it provides a supportive experience. Users appreciate when a JITAI integrates into their daily lives and offers timely help.
Social Support and Integration
There's a mixed opinion about including social features in JITAIs. Some participants thought it could be beneficial to connect with others, while others worried about the potential for negative interactions. The general consensus was that any kind of social component should be optional.
Privacy Concerns
Participants had varying opinions about privacy. Some were concerned about how their data would be used, while others didn’t mind sharing information if it meant they could get better support. Still, there was an emphasis on keeping data sharing voluntary and being transparent about its use.
Future Directions
While JITAIs for smoking cessation are promising, more research is needed to fine-tune their design and effectiveness. The goal is to make them as user-friendly as possible while also ensuring they offer meaningful support. Engaging a wider range of participants in future studies will help to refine these tools further.
Conclusion
In a world where smoking still poses significant health risks, finding new and effective ways to help people quit is essential. JITAIs offer a modern solution by providing timely, personalized support through technology. As research continues and methods improve, we may find ourselves better equipped to tackle the challenges of smoking cessation.
So, What’s Next?
If you’re thinking about quitting smoking or know someone who is, the future looks promising. With the right tools in hand, the journey could be a little less daunting. Who wouldn’t want a buddy on their phone cheering them on in their quest to become smoke-free? The science of quitting smoking is evolving, and surely, we’ll see more helpful solutions popping up before we know it.
So, let’s light up the way to a smoke-free future... just not with a cigarette!
Original Source
Title: Exploring perspectives on digital smoking cessation just-in-time adaptive interventions: A focus group study with adult smokers and smoking cessation professionals
Abstract: Technology-mediated just-in-time adaptive interventions (JITAIs), which provide users with real-time, tailored behavioural support, are a promising innovation for smoking cessation. However, a greater understanding of stakeholder, including user, perspectives on JITAIs is needed. Focus groups with UK-based adult smokers (three groups; N=19) and smoking cessation professionals (one group; N=5) were conducted January-June 2024. Topic guides addressed the integration of a JITAI into users lives and care provision, preferred content and features, and data and privacy. Transcripts and observational notes were analysed using Framework Analysis, guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework and the Technology Acceptance Model. Four major themes, "Smoking Cessation Process", "JITAI Characteristics", "Perceived Value of the JITAI", and "Relationship with the JITAI", and 16 subordinate themes were identified. The smoking cessation process was described as a challenging and idiosyncratic, non-linear journey during which a JITAI should provide consistent support. Preferences for specific JITAI characteristics varied. However, participants consistently expressed that a JITAI should be highly personalised and offer both immediate, interruptive support and ambient, in-depth content. The perceived usefulness and ease of use of a JITAI were described as central to its perceived value. Participants stressed that a JITAI would need to be convenient enough to easily integrate into its users daily lives, yet disruptive enough to facilitate behaviour change. Overall, smokers expressed that they would want their relationship with a JITAI to feel supportive and non-judgmental. They also felt a JITAI should promote, rather than infringe on, their autonomy. Smoking cessation professionals stressed the importance of privacy and data protection, whereas smokers appeared more ambivalent and had mixed opinions about this topic. JITAIs will need to balance aspects such as convenience and disruption and interruptive and ambient content while also addressing concerns related to privacy and autonomy to meet stakeholders needs and preferences. Author SummaryJust-in-time adaptive interventions (JITAIs) are new digital tools that can provide personalised, real-time support for people trying to change their behaviour. To help us understand how a JITAI could help people stop smoking, we conducted focus group discussions with adult smokers and smoking cessation professionals. We explored how a JITAI could fit into the daily lives and care of people trying to quit smoking, what it should do, and how concerned people were about data collection and privacy. Our findings indicate that a JITAI needs to strike a balance between being easy to use and providing enough disruption to help smokers change their behaviour. People in our focus groups felt that a JITAI should be flexible and personalised. They wanted it to act like a supportive friend, without being controlling. They also thought it should include both immediate, on-the-spot assistance and more detailed, reflective content. Privacy was an important concern for some, particularly for professionals, although some smokers were less concerned about this issue. Overall, our findings suggest that JITAIs need to be thoughtfully designed to respect user preferences, offer flexible and varied forms of support, and address privacy concerns to support people trying to quit smoking.
Authors: Corinna Leppin, Tosan Okpako, Claire Garnett, Olga Perski, Jamie Brown
Last Update: Nov 30, 2024
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.11.26.24317795
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.11.26.24317795.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.