Addressing Diversity in Canadian Medicine
A look at mentorship for Black medical students in Canada.
Chikaodili Obetta, Anjali Menezes, Nivetha Chandran, Onaope Egbedeyi, Maryam Taghavi, Modupe Tunde-Byass, Catherine Yu, Csilla Kalocsai, Umberin Najeeb, Rukia Swaleh, Mireille Norris
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- Historical Context
- Importance of Representation
- The Role of Mentorship
- Black Physicians of Canada Mentorship Program
- How the Program Works
- Study Objective
- Data Collection and Participants
- Key Findings
- 1. Characteristics of Successful Mentorship
- 2. Program Administration
- 3. Program Benefits
- 4. Barriers to Effective Mentorship
- 5. Recommendations for Improvement
- Conclusion
- The Importance of Community
- Practical Takeaways
- Broader Impacts
- Looking Forward
- Original Source
The medical field is facing a big problem when it comes to diversity. In Canada, Black people make up 4.3% of the total population. However, they only represent 1.5% of the doctors in the country. This gap signals some serious challenges that Black medical students encounter on their path to become physicians. Studies have shown that many Black medical learners experience emotional strain and even leave their training early. There's a clear need for change.
Historical Context
Racial categories have been used for a long time, often to justify horrible things like slavery and colonialism. In modern times, these categories continue to exist in education and healthcare, making it tough for people from different backgrounds to get fair treatment. Medical schools, while claiming to be neutral, still show bias in everything from admissions to teaching. Tackling racism in medicine is essential, but it requires breaking down existing structures and building new, fairer ones.
Importance of Representation
Having more Black doctors in hospitals isn’t just a nice idea – it has real Health Benefits. When Black doctors treat Black patients, it often leads to better health outcomes. Cultural awareness in medical training helps future doctors better serve their Communities. Plus, patient survival rates can improve when there’s a match between the race of the doctor and the patient. That’s why Mentorship programs focusing on Black medical students are becoming popular.
The Role of Mentorship
Mentorship is crucial in any tough job, especially in medicine. It can make a big difference for people going through stressful times, like intensive training or career decisions. Good mentors can help Black medical learners not just with academics but also with personal hurdles. Studies show that mentorship in medical settings often leads to higher satisfaction and better career retention.
Black Physicians of Canada Mentorship Program
In 2020, a survey revealed that many Black medical students and early-career doctors in Canada lacked mentors. Almost 80% of Black residents wanted a mentor who could relate to their experiences. In response, the Black Physicians of Canada (BPC) created a mentorship program specifically for these learners. This program began in July 2021 and aimed to provide guidance through mentorship that honors shared racial backgrounds.
How the Program Works
The BPC mentorship program paired Black medical trainees with mentors who had similar backgrounds. They organized regular meetings and events to create a sense of community. The mentors helped mentees not only academically but also personally. Topics like dealing with microaggressions and understanding finances in medicine were discussed openly.
Study Objective
To find out how effective this mentorship program was, researchers examined the experiences of both mentors and mentees. They focused on what made mentorship successful and what challenges the participants faced. By understanding these dynamics, they hoped to provide insights into making the program better.
Data Collection and Participants
The study involved 58 pairs of mentors and mentees who participated in their first year of the BPC program. Both groups answered surveys and participated in interviews. The feedback helped researchers collect a wide range of opinions and experiences.
Key Findings
1. Characteristics of Successful Mentorship
Both mentors and mentees highlighted the importance of good communication and a supportive relationship. Mentees appreciated mentors who provided honest feedback and shared their expertise. Not surprisingly, shared racial and gender identities helped strengthen the bond between mentors and mentees. These connections allowed mentees to feel understood and supported in their struggles.
2. Program Administration
The program was well-organized, with regular communication keeping participants engaged. Mentees appreciated being paired with mentors who had similar interests and specialties. Attendance at events was generally high, but participants wished for more face-to-face interactions.
3. Program Benefits
The mentorship program created a supportive space where participants felt comfortable discussing not only career-related topics but personal challenges as well. This holistic approach helped participants navigate issues unique to Black professionals, such as racism and financial struggles. Almost all mentees reported satisfaction with the program.
4. Barriers to Effective Mentorship
Despite the positive aspects, several challenges persisted. Mentors often had demanding schedules, which made it tough for them to commit time. Additionally, geographical distance sometimes hindered effective communication. Some mentor-mentee pairs had to rely solely on virtual communication, which wasn’t always ideal.
5. Recommendations for Improvement
Participants had many suggestions for making the program even better. Mentors wanted additional training on how to guide Black medical students effectively. They also suggested more networking opportunities beyond the immediate community. Furthermore, the pairing process could be improved by considering the long-term career goals of mentees to ensure better matches.
Conclusion
The BPC mentorship program represents an important step in addressing the needs of Black medical learners in Canada. The study reveals that having mentors who share similar experiences and backgrounds can greatly benefit students. However, barriers still exist that need to be addressed for the program to reach its full potential. By improving mentorship strategies and offering more support, future Black medical professionals can receive the guidance they need to succeed in their careers.
The Importance of Community
Creating a community isn't just about having a support system; it's about building a sense of belonging. Many Black medical students miss out on this feeling, which can lead to burnout and other issues. Strong community ties can help students feel like they have a place, leading to better mental health and academic performance.
Practical Takeaways
There are some practical steps that institutions can take to improve mentorship and support for Black medical learners. First, investment in mentorship networks can help ensure a steady flow of mentors for students. Second, creating dedicated spaces for Black students to connect with each other can foster community and belonging. Lastly, institutions must prioritize the mental well-being of Black medical learners by ensuring safe spaces for discussions and support.
Broader Impacts
The work done through mentorship programs like the BPC can have ripple effects. As more Black doctors enter the field, they can inspire future generations. Changing the landscape of medicine starts with small steps and supportive initiatives. With time, these can lead to systemic change within healthcare as a whole.
Looking Forward
In summary, the journey of Black medical students in Canada is a challenging one, but it is also filled with potential. By focusing on mentorship, community, and support, we can help pave the way for a more diverse and effective medical workforce. And who knows? The next generation might just find success in ways we can't even predict yet. Remember, the future is bright, especially when everyone gets a chance to shine!
Original Source
Title: Mentoring Matters: Evaluating The Black Physicians of Canada Mentorship Program
Abstract: PurposeBlack individuals face significant barriers in medicine, contributing to their underrepresentation as physicians and emphasizing the need for systemic change. From admissions processes to program design, medical schools often uphold outdated racial practices that disadvantage Black learners. Increased representation in medical schools benefits learners and improves care for diverse patient populations. Mentorship has proven essential in fostering success in higher education and can mitigate barriers to career progression. However, many Black learners face barriers to accessing quality mentorship despite its proven benefits in fostering equitable opportunities and career progression. The Scarborough Charter outlined 58 Canadian institutions committed to advancing Black inclusion in higher education through mentorship and accountability measures. In alignment with this goal, the Black Physicians of Canada (BPC) launched a racially concordant mentorship program. This study aimed to explore participants experiences and provide recommendations for future program iterations. MethodsThis study employed a convergent triangulation mixed methods design. Both quantitative and qualitative data were collected. The Yukawa Mentorship Evaluation Tool was used to measure program effectiveness. Descriptive analyses were conducted by a member of the research team. Data was coded by two members of the research team and findings were audited for consistency. ResultsA total of 51 participants (27 mentors, 24 mentees) completed the survey, and 13 (7 mentors, 6 mentees) participated in semi-structured interviews. Five themes emerged: Mentorship Characteristics, Program Administration, Perceived Program Benefits, Barriers to Mentorship, and Recommendations for Improvement. ConclusionThe BPC mentorship program represents a historic step toward addressing unmet needs of Black medical residents in Canada. Participants expressed high satisfaction and highlighted areas for improvement. Racially concordant mentorship was seen as particularly valuable in addressing unique challenges faced by Black learners. The findings from this study provide critical insights into best practices for future mentorship programs, advancing diversity and equity in medicine while supporting Black learners success.
Authors: Chikaodili Obetta, Anjali Menezes, Nivetha Chandran, Onaope Egbedeyi, Maryam Taghavi, Modupe Tunde-Byass, Catherine Yu, Csilla Kalocsai, Umberin Najeeb, Rukia Swaleh, Mireille Norris
Last Update: 2024-12-08 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.07.24318652
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.07.24318652.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.