Winter Illnesses Strain UK Healthcare Workers
Healthcare workers face rising respiratory illnesses during winter, impacting their health and workload.
Sarah Foulkes, Katie Munro, Dominic Sparkes, Jonathan Broad, Naomi Platt, Anna Howells, Omolola Akinbami, Jameel Khawam, Palak Joshi, Sophie Russell, Chris Norman, Lesley Price, Diane Corrigan, Michelle Cole, Jean Timelin, Louise Forster, Katrina Slater, Conall H Watson, Nick Andrews, Andre Charlett, Ana Atti, Jasmin Islam, Colin S Brown, Jonathan Turner, Susan Hopkins, Victoria Hall
― 6 min read
Table of Contents
- The Impact of COVID-19 on Understanding Seasonal Viruses
- SIREN Study: A Look into Healthcare Workers' Health
- The Purpose of the Winter Pressures Sub-Study
- How Participants Were Selected
- Symptoms and Sick Leave: What the Data Showed
- Understanding the Rates of Sick Leave
- Factors Influencing Time Off Work
- Conclusion: What We Learned
- Original Source
Every winter, the UK healthcare system finds itself in a bit of a pickle. During this chilly season, there’s a noticeable increase in respiratory viruses, particularly Influenza and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). These illnesses can cause a surge in patients visiting hospitals, leading to a strain on healthcare workers (HCWs), who also find themselves getting sick. In fact, respiratory illness is the second most common reason for Sick Leave in the NHS. To tackle this, the NHS runs a winter flu vaccine campaign aimed at healthcare workers to keep them healthy and minimize the spread of illnesses in hospitals.
COVID-19 on Understanding Seasonal Viruses
The Impact ofThroughout the pandemic, there has been a lot of focus on COVID-19, leading to a better grasp of how it spreads and how antibodies work to protect us. Unfortunately, the same level of understanding hasn't been developed for other seasonal viruses like influenza and RSV, which mainly affect those at higher risk, such as young children and the elderly. This lack of research on influenza and RSV has left healthcare workers, who are frequently exposed to these illnesses, somewhat in the dark. Investigating these illnesses in working-age populations could shed light on their prevalence and overall impact.
SIREN Study: A Look into Healthcare Workers' Health
To tackle these challenges, a study called SIREN was established in the UK. This study closely monitors healthcare workers by regularly testing them for COVID-19, collecting data on their symptoms, and tracking their Vaccination status. Since the study started in June 2020, it has continuously adapted to answer critical questions about the risk of re-infection with COVID-19 and the overall health of healthcare workers.
During the pandemic, a number of measures, such as wearing masks and keeping a distance, helped lower the rates of other respiratory viruses. However, with these protective measures lifted, winter 2022/23 provided the first real look at how these seasonal viruses affected healthcare workers. To gain insights, the SIREN study introduced a special ‘Winter Pressures sub-study’ to test for RSV and influenza along with COVID-19.
The Purpose of the Winter Pressures Sub-Study
The main goal of this Winter Pressures sub-study was threefold. First, it aimed to describe the number of cases of influenza, RSV, and COVID-19 among healthcare workers. Secondly, it sought to investigate the symptoms reported by these workers. Finally, the study aimed to assess how much time healthcare workers took off due to feeling unwell.
How Participants Were Selected
Participants for the study were recruited in two main ways. Those who had previously been involved in COVID-19 testing were informed and given the choice to stick around or step back. In addition to this, new participants were invited to join the study as well, ensuring a diverse group of healthcare workers.
Testing took place from late November 2022 to the end of March 2023. Participants filled out surveys every two weeks regarding their symptoms and time off work, while also providing information on their background and vaccination history to give researchers a clearer picture of their health and work-life.
Symptoms and Sick Leave: What the Data Showed
Over the analysis period, a significant number of participants reported feeling unwell. In fact, around 68.3% of those involved in the study experienced symptoms, and out of those, about 18% reported symptoms typical of influenza. Interestingly, many infections went unnoticed as they were asymptomatic. For example, nearly half of those with influenza reported no symptoms at all.
When it came to taking time off work, participants who tested positive for COVID-19 and RSV were more likely to stay home, with about 50% citing symptoms as the reason for their absence. On the other hand, only about 28.6% of those diagnosed with influenza reported needing to take time off.
On average, those who took sick leave due to COVID-19 had a median of five days off work, while those with influenza took about three days and RSV patients took four days. Overall, around 23% of all participants reported needing sick leave during the analysis period.
Understanding the Rates of Sick Leave
During the winter period, a grand total of 507,388 follow-up days were tracked, resulting in a sick leave rate of 1.48 days per 100 days worked. The peak rate of sick leave occurred in early December 2022, hitting 2.4 days per 100 days of follow-up. It seems that winter really does bring a flurry of illnesses, and healthcare workers are not immune to the effects.
Factors Influencing Time Off Work
The study also revealed that various factors influenced how much time healthcare workers took off due to illness. Those working in office settings tended to take fewer sick days compared to their colleagues in clinical roles, such as those working in intensive care units or operating theatres.
Moreover, those with existing health conditions, such as chronic respiratory issues, tended to take more time off. Notably, vaccination status played a role too. Those who had received both the COVID-19 vaccine and the seasonal flu shot tended to take less time off work compared to those who hadn’t been vaccinated at all.
Conclusion: What We Learned
The findings from the SIREN Winter Pressures pilot study paint a vivid picture of how respiratory illnesses impact the NHS workforce. The study highlights the importance of vaccines in reducing sick leave and the need for ongoing vigilance against respiratory illnesses among healthcare workers.
While the results were insightful, it’s important to note that the study faced some hurdles, including timings of testing and difficulties in tracking certain viruses. Despite these challenges, the pilot demonstrated that a better understanding of how seasonal viruses affect healthcare workers is crucial for ensuring the health and resilience of the NHS.
In conclusion, this study reinforces the idea that keeping healthcare workers healthy is not just a personal matter; it’s essential for the entire healthcare system. After all, without a healthy workforce, who will be there to look after us during the tough winters? So, if you see a healthcare worker this winter, maybe offer them a hot drink or a cozy blanket – they might just need it!
Original Source
Title: Adapting COVID-19 research infrastructure to capture influenza and respiratory syncytial virus alongside SARS-CoV-2 in UK healthcare workers winter 2022/23: Results of a pilot study in the SIREN cohort
Abstract: IntroductionThe combination of patient illness and staff absence driven by seasonal viruses culminates in annual "winter pressures" on UK healthcare systems and has been exacerbated by COVID-19. In winter 2022/23 we ran a pilot study aiming to introduce multiplex testing to determine the incidence and burden of SARS-CoV-2, influenza and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in our cohort of UK healthcare workers (HCWs). MethodsThe pilot study was conducted from 28/11/2022-31/03/2023 within the SIREN prospective cohort study. Participants completed fortnightly questionnaires, capturing symptoms and sick leave, and multiplex PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2, influenza and RSV, regardless of symptoms. PCR-positivity rates by virus were calculated over time, and viruses were compared by symptoms and severity. Self-reported symptoms and associated sick leave were described. Sick leave rates were compared by vaccination status and demographics. Results5,863 participants were included, 84.6% female, 70.3% [≥]45-years, and 33.4% were nurses. PCR-positivity peaked in early December for all three viruses (4.6 positives per 100 tests (95%CI 3.5, 5.7) SARS-CoV-2, 3.9 (95%CI 2.2, 5.6) influenza, 1.4 (95%CI 0.4, 2.4) RSV), declining to
Authors: Sarah Foulkes, Katie Munro, Dominic Sparkes, Jonathan Broad, Naomi Platt, Anna Howells, Omolola Akinbami, Jameel Khawam, Palak Joshi, Sophie Russell, Chris Norman, Lesley Price, Diane Corrigan, Michelle Cole, Jean Timelin, Louise Forster, Katrina Slater, Conall H Watson, Nick Andrews, Andre Charlett, Ana Atti, Jasmin Islam, Colin S Brown, Jonathan Turner, Susan Hopkins, Victoria Hall
Last Update: 2024-12-10 00:00:00
Language: English
Source URL: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.09.24318698
Source PDF: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.09.24318698.full.pdf
Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.
Thank you to medrxiv for use of its open access interoperability.