Sci Simple

New Science Research Articles Everyday

# Computer Science # Computation and Language # Artificial Intelligence

Understanding Trust in AI: A Comprehensive Guide

Explore the key factors influencing our trust in artificial intelligence systems.

Melanie McGrath, Harrison Bailey, Necva Bölücü, Xiang Dai, Sarvnaz Karimi, Cecile Paris

― 7 min read


Trust Issues in AI Trust Issues in AI artificial intelligence systems. Examining the complexities of trust in
Table of Contents

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly becoming a part of our daily lives. From voice assistants to self-driving cars, AI is transforming how we live and work. However, with this growth comes a big question: How much do we Trust AI? This article breaks down the factors that influence our trust in AI, making things clear and easy to understand.

What is Trust in AI?

Trust in AI means feeling confident that AI will do what we expect it to do. Just like any relationship, trust in AI can vary based on many different factors. Some people might trust AI a lot, while others might be more hesitant. Understanding why we trust AI is essential for developers and researchers, as it helps them create better and safer AI systems.

Why is Trust Important?

Trust is a big deal when it comes to using AI. If people don't trust AI systems, they may not want to use them. Imagine getting into a self-driving car—if you don’t trust it, you might just prefer a bus or even walking! So, understanding the reasons behind our trust (or lack thereof) is important for the future of technology. With solid trust in AI, we can expect more people to adopt it, making everyone's lives easier and more efficient.

The Factors That Affect Our Trust in AI

The factors that influence our trust in AI can be categorized into three main groups: human factors, technological factors, and contextual factors. Let’s break these down for clarity:

Human Factors

  1. Experience: People who have had positive Experiences with AI are more likely to trust it. For example, if your AI assistant always gets your music choices right, you may trust it more.

  2. Knowledge: Understanding how AI works can help build trust. If you know that your AI uses complex algorithms to analyze data, you might feel more confident in its decisions.

  3. Expectations: If people have high expectations for what AI can do, they may be more disappointed, leading to less trust when those expectations are not met.

Technological Factors

  1. Performance: The effectiveness of the AI system plays a huge role in trust. If an AI program consistently produces accurate results, users are more likely to trust it. On the other hand, if it malfunctions or makes mistakes, trust can quickly decline.

  2. Transparency: Knowing how AI makes its decisions can increase trust. For example, if an AI explains why it made a particular recommendation, users may trust it more than if it just presented the outcome without context.

  3. Reliability: People want to know that the AI will work every time they use it. Unpredictability can lead to distrust.

Contextual Factors

  1. Environment: The setting in which AI is used can impact trust. For instance, an AI used in a home setting might be trusted more than one used in a critical medical situation.

  2. Social Dynamics: People are influenced by what others say about AI. If friends, family, or colleagues express confidence in an AI system, others may likely follow suit.

  3. Time Pressure: In situations where time is limited, individuals are less likely to take the time to question AI decisions, which can lead to a default level of trust, whether justified or not.

The Challenge of Trust in AI

Trusting AI is not always straightforward. With so many variables in play, it can be tough to determine which factors matter most. Researchers are trying to gather all this information to help people better understand and trust AI.

Building a Better Understanding of Trust

To make sense of all these factors, researchers have created a structured dataset that includes information about trust in AI. This resource aims to collate insights from scientific literature, making it easier for researchers to study what influences trust and how to improve it.

Creating the Dataset

Building this dataset is no small task. It requires input from experts, who help identify the key factors and how they relate to trust. As they gather information, they aim to include a wide range of AI applications to cover various scenarios.

Annotating the Information

To make the dataset practical, researchers annotate it. This means they go through the gathered information and label different parts based on the factors that influence trust. For example, they identify whether an AI application is human-focused, technology-focused, or context-focused.

The Role of Large Language Models

Researchers have started using large language models (LLMs) to help with the annotation process. These AI systems can assist in identifying and classifying the information quickly, but there is still a need for human oversight. The combination of AI and human intelligence helps ensure that the most accurate data is gathered.

Results and Findings

After collecting and annotating all the data, researchers can analyze it to see trends and commonalities. They can observe which factors are most influential in building trust across different AI applications.

Supervised Learning vs. Large Language Models

When comparing the results of supervised learning with that of LLMs, researchers found that traditional supervised methods tend to perform better in many cases. This finding emphasizes the importance of human-curated data and shows that while LLMs can be helpful, they aren't a complete replacement for human expertise.

Challenges Faced

As researchers delve into this area, they face several challenges. Trust in AI is a nuanced topic, and not all factors are clearly defined. Some words can mean different things depending on the context, making it tricky to classify them correctly. Additionally, the relationship between trust and various factors is often complex and hard to pin down.

The Importance of Clear Guidelines

To overcome some of these challenges, researchers create clear guidelines for annotating the dataset. These guidelines help annotators understand what to look for when identifying factors and relationships. By having a structured approach, they can ensure that the dataset is reliable and useful.

Future Directions

The study of trust in AI is just beginning. There is much to learn and explore. Researchers hope to expand their dataset further, including more applications and contexts. They also want to improve the way they handle entity resolution, which means identifying when different terms refer to the same concept.

Addressing Ethical Concerns

As with any research involving data, there are ethical considerations. The dataset is built using publicly available scientific literature, which means it respects copyright. Researchers are careful to provide links rather than redistributing entire papers without permission.

Language Limitations

Currently, the dataset is focused solely on English-language literature. This focus might limit its usefulness for non-English-speaking researchers or communities. Expanding the dataset to include other languages could provide a more global perspective on trust in AI.

Human Element

The people involved in creating the dataset come from different backgrounds, ensuring a diverse range of perspectives. One annotator is an expert in trust and psychology, while another is studying computer science and politics. This diversity helps provide a well-rounded view of the topic.

Conclusion

In summary, trust in AI is a multi-faceted issue influenced by various human, technological, and contextual factors. As AI continues to grow in importance, understanding the dynamics of trust will become even more critical. By building structured datasets, researchers aim to shed light on this complex area, helping to create AI systems that we can all trust.

So next time you use your AI assistant, remember it's not just about technology; it's about trust and the many factors that shape it! That’s the magic behind the AI curtain!

Original Source

Title: Can AI Extract Antecedent Factors of Human Trust in AI? An Application of Information Extraction for Scientific Literature in Behavioural and Computer Sciences

Abstract: Information extraction from the scientific literature is one of the main techniques to transform unstructured knowledge hidden in the text into structured data which can then be used for decision-making in down-stream tasks. One such area is Trust in AI, where factors contributing to human trust in artificial intelligence applications are studied. The relationships of these factors with human trust in such applications are complex. We hence explore this space from the lens of information extraction where, with the input of domain experts, we carefully design annotation guidelines, create the first annotated English dataset in this domain, investigate an LLM-guided annotation, and benchmark it with state-of-the-art methods using large language models in named entity and relation extraction. Our results indicate that this problem requires supervised learning which may not be currently feasible with prompt-based LLMs.

Authors: Melanie McGrath, Harrison Bailey, Necva Bölücü, Xiang Dai, Sarvnaz Karimi, Cecile Paris

Last Update: 2024-12-15 00:00:00

Language: English

Source URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.11344

Source PDF: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2412.11344

Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Changes: This summary was created with assistance from AI and may have inaccuracies. For accurate information, please refer to the original source documents linked here.

Thank you to arxiv for use of its open access interoperability.

Similar Articles